or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - Page 1386

post #20776 of 46573
They have a walnut/bone longwing spectator available in my size. If I weren't already in the process of buying shell MacNeils per Mr. G's offer from last month, I would be ALL OVER THAT. What a good-looking shoe. nod[1].gif
post #20777 of 46573
Quote:
Originally Posted by random-adam View Post

They have a walnut/bone longwing spectator available in my size. If I weren't already in the process of buying shell MacNeils per Mr. G's offer from last month, I would be ALL OVER THAT. What a good-looking shoe. nod[1].gif

I thought the same on the long wing, and also have a custom shell MacNeil on the way. I am interested in the brown/walnut wing; it kinda reminds me of Nucky Thompson's shoes. Undecided if I should pull the trigger.
post #20778 of 46573


I decided to return the strands in black and get the fifth avenues. Man these things are the most comfortable dress shoes I've ever worn. The right heel has a bit of slippage but I bought some heel slip thingy to put in.

Happy that I got something more plain
post #20779 of 46573
Quote:
Originally Posted by MoneyWellSpent View Post

It isn't really a coincidence.  Brooks Brothers is apparently the supplier of clothing for the film (see their website).  AE has made shoes as a part of the Gatsby collection, and I assume they may have been part of the costumes for the movie.  Just speculating on that, but it makes sense. 

Historically I'm not sure if AE had gained traction yet with the mass market. As their original founding was 1922, but I'm more saying they are timing the release of this Webern but am not sure if they actually have a sponsorship or official nod by the move folks. This is speculation as well though.
post #20780 of 46573
Quote:
Originally Posted by 7_rocket View Post



I decided to return the strands in black and get the fifth avenues. Man these things are the most comfortable dress shoes I've ever worn. The right heel has a bit of slippage but I bought some heel slip thingy to put in.

Happy that I got something more plain

 

One thing from all these post is for sure...we all work in places with basically the same UGLY carpet  happy.gif

post #20781 of 46573
Quote:
Originally Posted by 7_rocket View Post



I decided to return the strands in black and get the fifth avenues. Man these things are the most comfortable dress shoes I've ever worn. The right heel has a bit of slippage but I bought some heel slip thingy to put in.

Happy that I got something more plain

 

Those look great!

post #20782 of 46573
Thanks Money! i'm amazed by the quality and comfort of these. My Kenilworth took a while to break in but these feel so much more comfortable out the box
post #20783 of 46573
Quote:
Originally Posted by jrarnold View Post

Is it a good idea to lace your shoes up tightly for storage with shoe trees? Or is this just done for appearance in the photo?
I don't think you need to for storage. I tried one time, but the shoe trees do not fill out the shoe like my foot does so does not replicate the shape when fully tied. It is also is one more step when putting your shoes on, untie and spread throat apart to insert foot, whereas if you left
Quote:
Originally Posted by WICaniac View Post

A thread from several years ago contemplated the question of whether AEs are too "blobby."  While the consensus opinion was (I think) "no,"  my wife is concerned that the Franciscans I just bought during the 91st anniversary sale aren't blobby enough.  That is to say she finds the 3-333 last on which the shoe is built to be too long, and from certain angles she thinks these look like "clown shoes." Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

That's not what AE was going for: "Slightly elongated profile with a square toe shape for a more euro look."
My wardrobe is neither fashion forward nor conservative--more retro-edgy (think BB's new Gatsby line).  So while I expect that most AE aficionados will disagree with my wife, I wonder whether this ought to be my mainstay (3 days a week) shoe for the foreseeable future.  Thoughts?
Yes agreed that the 3 last is more European. I think I am shying away from the chiseled look as I don't think it will stand the test of time as much, so I am only looking for shoes that are more rounded now.

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Shoes1 View Post

SWIMS are great.  I have two pairs, one I got from BB for $60 and another pair from AE for $30.  Don't pay full pricel; buy them on sale.
Agreed. I scored two pair (Red and Brown) from the AE outlet for $30/pair a while back.
post #20784 of 46573

I have the kenilworth, in the same size as my 5th aves (both 5-last), but the kenilworth feels noticeably bigger/longer...I believe this is a pretty common observation with the kenilworth vs. the PA/5A/Strands (I wish I had known sooner). 

 

I've already worn the kenilworth out a few times scratching the leather sole, so an exchange/return is probably out of the question.  I was hoping/optimistic it would somehow fit me better eventually.  You guys have any advice on what I can possibly do?  My last resort would be to ebay them at a loss =/

post #20785 of 46573
Quote:
Originally Posted by charliebrown2 View Post

I have the kenilworth, in the same size as my 5th aves (both 5-last), but the kenilworth feels noticeably bigger/longer...I believe this is a pretty common observation with the kenilworth vs. the PA/5A/Strands (I wish I had known sooner). 

I've already worn the kenilworth out a few times scratching the leather sole, so an exchange/return is probably out of the question.  I was hoping/optimistic it would somehow fit me better eventually.  You guys have any advice on what I can possibly do?  My last resort would be to ebay them at a loss =/

I have the kenilworth as mentioned and I had to size down half a size from my normal dress shoes which is size 8. I'm 8 in the fifth avenue.

Maybe use insoles?
post #20786 of 46573
Quote:
Originally Posted by tampatravel View Post

Thanks for the props! It was jvc44 who started this mess. It's amazing how a stranger on a forum can help you part with $300! smile.gif



I'm still wearing mine around the house - breaking them in...I haven't worn them out yet. They're making their maiden voyage next week. I did buy the Alden Leather Defender to put on them. That goes on cloudy and polishes up great. I picked some up in San Fran at the Alden store...which is a must stop if you're in town. It's literally a block away from the AE store too.
post #20787 of 46573
I was just trying to help you out!
post #20788 of 46573
Quote:
Originally Posted by Winston S. View Post


I don't think you need to for storage. I tried one time, but the shoe trees do not fill out the shoe like my foot does so does not replicate the shape when fully tied. It is also is one more step when putting your shoes on, untie and spread throat apart to insert foot, whereas if you left
Yes agreed that the 3 last is more European. I think I am shying away from the chiseled look as I don't think it will stand the test of time as much, so I am only looking for shoes that are more rounded now.
Agreed. I scored two pair (Red and Brown) from the AE outlet for $30/pair a while back.

Winston-

 

Did you make the SWIMS purchase in December like the other member did? I really want these but am not interested in paying full price.

 

Thanks

post #20789 of 46573
Quote:
Originally Posted by jvc44 View Post

I was just trying to help you out!


...and you certainly helped us all out. I love my Townley Cordovan shoes!

post #20790 of 46573
Quote:
Originally Posted by 7_rocket View Post


I have the kenilworth as mentioned and I had to size down half a size from my normal dress shoes which is size 8. I'm 8 in the fifth avenue.

Maybe use insoles?


I wish I had properly did some research, as you've done.  Maybe I'll look into insoles, never have before.  Thanks.

 

Open to any other advice as well.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread