or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - Page 1329

post #19921 of 52497
Quote:
Originally Posted by DerangedGoose View Post

I just received Kenilworths off ebay, and I have two questions:

 

1) has anyone here noticed the weird lump under the ball of your foot? I saw someone posted a review on the AE website noting the same problem. Its almost like you can feel the shank or something

 

2) there is a crack on the back heel tab. Should I color it in with meltonian, or should I return the shoes? They were pretty cheap and are in spotless condition otherwise:

 

 

 

If the shoes do not feel like a great fit now, then they will not improve.  And if there is a noticeable lump under your foot, that may cause more harm to your foot over time.  For these reasons, I would return them - and not the cosmetic issues.  (Every AE pair I have purchased came with that great fit and ready to wear - with no break-in time)

 

However - the picture you posted of the heel does not look like a Kenilworth to me.  I went to eBay to look at the "completed sales" within the last 2 months - and the photos of the heels appear of a different style than of the one you posted.

 

Below are some photos of what the Kenilworth heels look like (which is unique):

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by matty long legs View Post

Wingham loafer bought brand new at a thrift store on Tuesday.

 

A Thrift Store purchase?  Dare I ask how much?

 

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by AZsundevil View Post

So if anybody was interested in this comment thread, I got a response back from AE customer service. The shoes are gone. Let this be a lesson: If you see a Webgem that you like, BUY IT, because AE can and will pull them at their discretion.

Web Gems anyone: 

 

post #19922 of 52497
Quote:
Originally Posted by GOP Shoe Guy View Post

I believe he mentioned old styles that were no longer being made as long as they had the dies, and also having shoes made in another color if they had the leather.

Wow. I'd love to get a pair of the Bourbon & Bone McClains that they've stopped making.
post #19923 of 52497
Quote:
Originally Posted by aj555 View Post

Got a couple questions...
Went to Nordstrom rack with the wife the other day, and ran across a pair of AE boat shoes that were exactly what I was looking for and fit perfect. I know being Nordstrom rack they are an older outdated pair. I'm curious as to which ones they are. I've tried searching, but can't find them online at all anywhere. They were stuck in a fairfax box, so that doesn't help to id them. Do any of you guys know?



If you post a photo of the stamped codes that appear inside the shoe, it would help in tracking down more information.
post #19924 of 52497
Quote:
Originally Posted by aj555 View Post

Got a couple questions...

Went to Nordstrom rack with the wife the other day, and ran across a pair of AE boat shoes that were exactly what I was looking for and fit perfect. I know being Nordstrom rack they are an older outdated pair. I'm curious as to which ones they are. I've tried searching, but can't find them online at all anywhere. They were stuck in a fairfax box, so that doesn't help to id them. Do any of you guys know?

 

 

Next question, I'm getting a pair of Dalton's in Walnut within the next couple days. I want to get the black patina look on the toe and heel. I've looked up how to do this, but still have some questions. Should I use black wax or polish? Should I use a walnut polish first, then add the black wax/polish? Should I layer the polishes differently, and how often should I use the black? 

 

Thanks

 

1)  As suggested - just post the series of numbers located inside the shoe.  (By the way, that is one of the best looking set of boat shoes I have seen)

 

2)  For the Dalton instructions, the best source of instructions and superior products would be in the following link:

 

http://www.hangerproject.com/closet/shoe-care-guide/shoe-antiquing-the-new-old.html

 

David

post #19925 of 52497
Quote:
Originally Posted by random-adam View Post


If you post a photo of the stamped codes that appear inside the shoe, it would help in tracking down more information.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by David Copeland View Post

1)  As suggested - just post the series of numbers located inside the shoe.  (By the way, that is one of the best looking set of boat shoes I have seen)

 

2)  For the Dalton instructions, the best source of instructions and superior products would be in the following link:

 

http://www.hangerproject.com/closet/shoe-care-guide/shoe-antiquing-the-new-old.html

 

David

Here you go:

 

Not sure which number you need: 48255 & 0018405

 

 

David, thank you for the compliment, and thanks for the link.

post #19926 of 52497

Maiden voyage of the shell Townleys today.

 

post #19927 of 52497
Quote:
Originally Posted by masernaut View Post

Yes, go with your 5 Last size and go up a width.

Quote:
Originally Posted by md2010 View Post

All RL models are on custom lasts. Sanderson is on customer last which is very similar to 2. I have sanderson and also ae players(on last 2). Sanderson runs narrow as. I have sanderson in 8E width and they feel like 8B. Unwearable. My players are 8EEE and I feel I could've done better with E or EE on players.


Gentlemen, thank you for your comments! I think I will stay away from the shoe for now - this forum is the next best thing as having an AE store close by.
post #19928 of 52497
Quote:
Originally Posted by kmdsimpson View Post

This is the problem I am having.. there are so many new posts each day now, that I miss when MoneyWellSpent answers a question before I've read his post! Excellent info, especially on the nails. I actually was wondering why some shoes have nails showing outside the heel and some don't.

And WTH has happened to this thread? I see 60+ new posts a day, and I assume there's a new controversy! But no, it's just people discussing shoes again. icon_gu_b_slayer[1].gif

I agree on ALL points! MWS is always worth the read and I enjoy them a lot. And yes it is great to be back to discussing shoes. And shoe pictures once again! 

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Michael Haines View Post

Via Paul's most gracious offer I just ordered a walnut shell Dundee. Cold iron it's your fault loved yours

Your welcome, that is why we post pictures- to enable others biggrin.gif

 

So last night I had my shell samples out and a couple pairs of shoes when the girlfriend came over. She said that I had told her there was a shortage of shell and asked what was I up to. I quoted your post from another thread where you read your wife about the shortage and she started crying and you told her not to worry. And she replied no they were tears of joy. My gf laughed so hard she actually cried. Thank you for that!

Quote:
Originally Posted by GOP Shoe Guy View Post

Sevenfold, I have sided with you. I ordered the MacNeil in Walnut Cordovan with the Reverse Double Redenbach sole in brown. I already own one pair of Williams... Thank everyone for the input.

Great choice IMO! Erhhh did anyone warn you how addicting shell is? smile.gif

Quote:
Originally Posted by bespoken pa View Post

GOP, can inquire what the bill was on the walnut shell?

When I talked to them about pricing she said whatever is current retail unless it was a webgem then pricing would be what it was when offered. Boots are more than shoes at $695 because there is more leather and sometimes more work involved.

Quote:
Originally Posted by bespoken pa View Post

Is there much of a difference if at all between Alden s whiskey and AE walnut?
Quote:
Originally Posted by sevenfoldtieguy View Post

Many whiskey models would be a bit lighter in color, with more of a butterscotch hue - but certainly the two colors have similarities.

I was surprised to find that walnut is closer to ravello than whiskey, without the red tint in ravello of course. Whiskey must be a very light color. I don't need to know, I don't need to know, I don't need...

Quote:
Originally Posted by bucksfan View Post

... And here they are... Love that fast shipping!

Side note: not much paste wax to try to remove - maybe they are listening!


Outstanding! I have the brown and am considering the burgundy. Someday...

Quote:
Originally Posted by random-adam View Post

In the second place, it's good to hear about their light hand on the paste wax.

In the first place -- those look fantastic! I just pulled the trigger on some burgundy shell MacNeils; I wonder if Mr. Grangaard's offer might persist for another few months of ramen-and-PBJ diet so I can afford a pair of 14AAA walnut shell Patriots...

When I talked to the SWAT team yesterday she said there is no expiration on Paul's offer. 

Quote:
Originally Posted by MakingChanges View Post

Mine should be here today, along with the New Orleans. The Amoks just arrived yesterday from the Amazon sale. I'm only going to keep either the Amok or the Karmai. I don't have any boots at this juncture, which ones do you think are more versatile?

The right answer is to keep both of course.... My personal preference is the Katmai however. When you get both see what you think and how it fits in with what you will wear them with.

post #19929 of 52497

I received my Merlot McAllister firsts, and while they're otherwise great, I'm a little bothered with the toe caps. In particular, there's a very obvious ridge between the toe cap structure and the rest of the uppers. As much as I want to keep them (and wear them to a wedding today), I'm think I'm going to return them for replacements. I feel that I'm being a tad picky, but I'm also quite sure if I didn't return them I'd likely always look at them and wish I did. If they were seconds, it would be another story. Any comments on how common this minor problem is?

 

 

post #19930 of 52497
Quote:
Originally Posted by kentyman View Post

I received my Merlot McAllister firsts, and while they're otherwise great, I'm a little bothered with the toe caps. In particular, there's a very obvious ridge between the toe cap structure and the rest of the uppers. As much as I want to keep them (and wear them to a wedding today), I'm think I'm going to return them for replacements. I feel that I'm being a tad picky, but I'm also quite sure if I didn't return them I'd likely always look at them and wish I did. If they were seconds, it would be another story. Any comments on how common this minor problem is?

 

 

 

FWIW, I don't have those types of ridges on my merlot mcallisters.  Did they come like that or did they show up after trying them on, perhaps they are too long?

 

 

 

744 LTDs after a round of Saphir Reno.  Don't want to admit it, but the stuff is pretty damn good and pricy.  I wonder what the next iteration of the Wolverine x AE collaboration will be?  I'll be saving my pennies up for them.  Both so far have been outstanding.

post #19931 of 52497
Quote:
Originally Posted by kentyman View Post

I received my Merlot McAllister firsts, and while they're otherwise great, I'm a little bothered with the toe caps. In particular, there's a very obvious ridge between the toe cap structure and the rest of the uppers. As much as I want to keep them (and wear them to a wedding today), I'm think I'm going to return them for replacements. I feel that I'm being a tad picky, but I'm also quite sure if I didn't return them I'd likely always look at them and wish I did. If they were seconds, it would be another story. Any comments on how common this minor problem is?




Return them.
post #19932 of 52497

Got a call today from the store. My walnut McAllisters are in. I'll be picking them up when I get back into town. I'm pretty pumped about them because they are my first pair of quality shoes. Now I have to find the perfect pair of Burgundy Shell loafers.

post #19933 of 52497
Quote:
Originally Posted by WiredandTired View Post

744 LTDs after a round of Saphir Reno.  Don't want to admit it, but the stuff is pretty damn good and pricy.

 

LOL, I know that feeling... Great boots btw!

post #19934 of 52497
You people will be the death of me. I just ordered shell Patriots from Jeffersonville.
post #19935 of 52497
With the nice AE sale going on until the 29th. What shoes do you think will get discounted for the Memorial Day sale? Will it be a 50%
Sale like I've heard. Shall I by a pair now or two later. Any specifics you might have would be great.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread