They're too big; if I push my foot as far to the front of the shoe, I can fit 2 fingers behind my heel. I tried with the macallister and I can fit 1, 2 would be a stretch
I guess it's possible I should be in a 9.5D instead of a 10D? I have 4 other pairs of ae, and all of them I bought in the store
I was fitted as 10.5D. I believed 10.5D was my size all along. Turns out, I fit into a 9.5 EEE. 9 EEE maybe with thin socks.
Try different width if you think you have wide feet. Going from 10.5D -> 9.5 EEE was a huge surprise, but in hindsight, it was worth knowing my correct size.