Hm. I think I'm liking the Leeds in shell (though it's a blucher) or this Alden over the PA. I just can't past the PA's captoe. But hard to go wrong with any of them.
I like AE's PTB over Alden's, because of the Barrie last. The Alden for BB PTB last is nicer, but they have the eyelets that will eventually lose their paint... The Leeds are better IMO.
The thing about the Park ave toe cap is that it can vary so much from one shoe to the next. The pair I have in calf are pretty good in this regard, as the toe cap comes back fairly far. I have seen pics of others where it is definitely shorter than I'd like.
I do like the look of that punched cap toe bal though...