or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc... - Page 3707  

post #55591 of 70737

After seeing many comments regarding the SB, I decided to take a look. Found some PA's in my size for $249, thoughts on the price - is this a decent deal? Sorry for my lack of knowledge. 

post #55592 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by kbuzz View Post

Thanks everyone for the replies re my post about dalton and denim. Im think im sold. ...oops just saw...those cmxl longbranch's and they look stellar. lol

So one more dalton question for the forum: what color? I love the walnut but I live in a pair of CJ sonniston's "tan" (really more brown and incidentally the quality is unbelievable)
  Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)


are they too close in color? The oxblood aint too shabby either...Thanks again

 

If you don't have any oxblood yet, you owe it to yourself to get some.  Dazzling color.  And, the Dalton looks great in it.

post #55593 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zzen View Post
 

Single oak sole.

 

Shoes look pretty good for seconds, this is the first time I have ordered a pair.

 

There is some finish on the sole.  The edging is sloppy in places and has one large divot.  There is a small tear near one lace hole that probably isn't even big enough to see on a crappy iphone pic.  The right shoe medallion is also slightly off center, but not terribly so.

 

The sole just rubs me the wrong way for some reason.  I called ahead to inquire about the pair so you think they would have mentioned that detail.


I will think on it this weekend but I am leaning towards sending them back and just waiting for my war chest to be replenished so I can buy some firsts.

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

 

 

That looks like the new sole design - brand new, in fact. I'm sure it was a mistake to put it on these cordovan shoes, but at least you know they're a recent build. Who knows why that happened.

 

Quote:

Originally Posted by jcman311 View Post
 

Decision made.  Finally actually put them on.  Fit great.  Keepers.

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

 

 

Congrats and enjoy. They look great.

post #55594 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by JSO1 View Post
 

 

That looks like the new sole design - brand new, in fact. I'm sure it was a mistake to put it on these cordovan shoes, but at least you know they're a recent build. Who knows why that happened.

 

Congrats and enjoy. They look great.

 

Thanks for sharing the knowledge sir.

 

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by NWTeal View Post

@ZzenI think they look pretty good. I'd feel like getting a regular sole is a bit of a downer since part of the value for shell is the JR sole. What size are they?smile.gif

10.5D.  JR sole would definitely be better, but overall a pretty strong pair of seconds.

post #55595 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by Neo1 View Post


I debated on the Kenilworth a while but decided against it.  Maybe sometime I'll pick that up.  I can't remember now but I think it was you who said you could pretty much get away with wearing whatever you wanted (?) I work in a super conservative environment so all that talk about the walnut strand made me a little envious - wayyy to showy for me, although really nice looking.

Anyway, I wanted to note that I own the neumok in red - the pictures are NOT at all representative, the color is much duller / more burnished than it looks on the shoebank page.  I tried all four - I would actually consider the brown to be the most flashy, more so than either the blue or green.  I don't like my shoes to be the centerpiece of what I'm wearing - with a casual outfit I find that the red neumok works.  The brown one, no way.  With the current prices I would pull the trigger on the red or green if you don't have it already.

That was me. I work in IT and our dress code is "business casual". I can get away with wearing chinos if I wanted, but I like I to dress up a little more. The kenilworth interestingly enough I had to size down .5 from my normal size in the 5 last.

I've seen the neumok brown in person and I like how it looks. I don't think it's flashy at all but as someone said once you polish it, it will become darker.

All my shoes are in brown tones with the exception of my Lasalle in chili which is a FANTASTIC color. I'm going to google the red neumok's to see how they look thanks.

I like to have all different tones of brown and different colors such as chili and oxblood. More versatile this way
post #55596 of 70737

Just showed up. I suppose I'll have to break them in tonight onstage in a tuxedo. icon_gu_b_slayer[1].gif
post #55597 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by JSO1 View Post
 

 

That looks like the new sole design - brand new, in fact. I'm sure it was a mistake to put it on these cordovan shoes, but at least you know they're a recent build. Who knows why that happened.

 

Congrats and enjoy. They look great.

 

Also seems to be the new darker burgundy finish that AE has started doing that we saw with the GMTO Burgundy Strands. I really like it and hope anything I order in burgundy in the future is dark like that pair. Hopefully a pair of Dundees next up for me.

post #55598 of 70737
Gave the shoebank a try today for the first time, went with some Kenilworth and macneil seconds, both in dark burnished brown. Sick of paying retail.
post #55599 of 70737
Finally received my Bourbon Strands in the mail yesterday--the burnished finish is really nice, especially for the Strand. I think it suits the design very well:



However, my excitement was short lived when I got to the left shoe and noticed the following imperfections: (a) a cut on the broguing by the vamp on the left shoe, as well as some holes which were not cleanly punched through; and (b) wrinkling on the outer left shoe:





It's going back, unless they give me a killer deal to keep them. Oh well, at least it gave me an excuse to dust off the 5D2 and 35L for some pics. smile.gif
post #55600 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darkside View Post
 

 

Not to dissent from your opinion, but IMO the Macneil is a very bulky shoe with a double sole that lends more to casual looks. With fitted suits, I don't think the Macneil becomes a versatile choice. I second @peppercorn78's opinion on going for a sleek blucher in bourbon or burgundy. But to be completely honest, I have a pair of burgundy double monks that have proven to be useful in all situations.


You may be right, although I think this comes down to a question of personal style. Looking at the websites for companies like J. Crew, heck even Brooks Bros, I see lots of suits with bulky double-soled shoes. In the end, as a compromise shoe to go with suits, sc, and chinos, I think a suit with with a chunky double-soled shoe is a much more successful compromise than a sleeker more formal shoe with chinos.  

post #55601 of 70737

^^^jubu, I don't see the cut or the other imperfections you cited.

post #55602 of 70737
Black Hills with denim today.


Chris
post #55603 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by coolarrow View Post

^^^jubu, I don't see the cut or the other imperfections you cited.

Here's what is bothering me the most...the wrinkling I could overlook...

post #55604 of 70737
^I don't think anyone would notice that, unless they look at it a couple of centimeters away.
post #55605 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by LEgoiste View Post

^I don't think anyone would notice that, unless they look at it a couple of centimeters away.

I don't disagree with ya....If these were seconds, I'd probably be ok assuming I got a deal....but for firsts (and firsts pricing), I think they've got to go back.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
This thread is locked  
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc...