Thanks @Fred G. Unn . I called up the CAC and spoke with a great customer service rep about my situation and had two shoes of different sizes and lace style sent out. I'll update once I get them in.
As for the comments regarding the shoe being too narrow, the pictures I posted were of 12C wearing thin socks. The neumoks also pictured are 12D and in those same thin socks my feet are swimming in there. Going any wider to get that lacing closer just isn't going to be an option Im afraid. So i went longer to see if its going to work out with the closed lacing. I'll update when they arrive.