Ok, I tried this on the general Q&A but no love, and I thought, why not try on my favorite thread... To respect the thread and convey my true love of AE, I have crossed out shows that I might or might not actually have, and put the closest AE model that an AE-fan purer than myself would have.
So... I need to purge at least three pairs of shoes from this lineup (guess why). I'm having trouble so coming to you for some wise insight.
At work I am generally business casual, wear a suit (either navy or charcoal) occasionally. Jeans and cords on weekends.
Black Captoe Bal (AE Park Ave)
Merlot Wingtip Bals (AE McAlister)
burgundy Shell cordovan Plain Toe Bluchers (AE Leeds)
burgundy Shell cordovan long wings (old Florsheims) (AE MacNeil)
burgundy Shell Cordovan Penny Loafers (Alden LHS) (AE Patriot)
Brown captoe bluchers (Alden for BB) (AE Lexington)
Walnut "medallion perforated captoe" bals (Alfred Sargent for BB) (this in walnut) (Slightly less embellished AE Strand)
this weird kiltie monkstrap that for some reason I can't get myself to return (C&J for black fleece, talk me out of it please, they're new and unworn still) (http://www.brooksbrothers.com/Dark-Brown-Kiltie-Wingtip/FH00035,default,pd.html) (AE Montague???)
What shoed go?
Florsheims, Walnut captoes and CJ kiltie monks.