Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc...

[New Shoes1]

Thoughts on the Hillsborough?

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Allen-Edmon...15?pt=US_Men_s_Shoes&var=&hash=item3f14c09173

I am interested in getting my first loafer, but I'm not a big fan of the penny variety. I like the sleek lines and simplicity of this shoe. Does anyone own it and have in the wild pictures?

Not a fan at all. What about a tassel loafer if you're not a fan of penny loafers? What about a penny loafer in suede for something different?

 

[MZhammer]

Thoughts on the Hillsborough?

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Allen-Edmon...15?pt=US_Men_s_Shoes&var=&hash=item3f14c09173

I am interested in getting my first loafer, but I'm not a big fan of the penny variety. I like the sleek lines and simplicity of this shoe. Does anyone own it and have in the wild pictures?

Ooff no...

Big fan of the Graysons
http://www.allenedmonds.com/aeonline/producti_SF169_1_40000000001_-1

and I think the Randolph are sleek for penny loafers
http://www.allenedmonds.com/aeonline/producti_SF4809_1_40000000001_-1

As New Shoes1 aluded to, tassles are in right now.

 

[OptoDoc]

I would never judge anyone for wearing tassel loafers, but I can't see myself owning a pair. I find them to be quite 'dandy'. I like the way penny loafers look on the shelf, but every time I've tried on a pair I've thought they looked rather odd on my feet. Maybe I'll go the monk strap route for a no-lace shoe instead. Though, the simplicity of slipping into the Hillsborough was appealing...especially when it's raining, due to the rubber sole.

Has AE ever made a wholecut loafer? Something like this...



They have the Ann Arbor on the clearance list currently, but it has a cemented sole.

 

[MZhammer]

I would never judge anyone for wearing tassel loafers, but I can't see myself owning a pair. I find them to be quite 'dandy'. I like the way penny loafers look on the shelf, but every time I've tried on a pair I've thought they looked rather odd on my feet. Maybe I'll go the monk strap route for a no-lace shoe instead. Though, the simplicity of slipping into the Hillsborough was appealing...especially when it's raining, due to the rubber sole.

SWIMS has some new slip on loafers that would be good in summer showers, although they're bright.

 

[MrWN]

I just received my order of the El Paso from the tent sale. I think they decided to send me a pair of firsts rather than seconds; they look perfectly fine and no markings of seconds.

Note to self: El Paso in 10 E feels more like a 10 D... Will need to go 10 EE in the future for this shoe.

 

[jrarnold]

Quote:
There's always the Scottsdale, looks the same as a Patriot but it has the Gumlite/Vibram rubber sole normally. You said you didn't like the penny loafer look, but maybe you'd like the rubber sole already there?

 

[jrarnold]

Quote:
Is this look considered fashionable now? That tie looks awful; the cut and the color.

 

[MZhammer]

Is this look considered fashionable now? That tie looks awful; the cut and the color.

Luca Rubinacci is usually considered fashionable, albeit dandified.
If you're not familiar with him go take a look.

 

[David Copeland]

Luca Rubinacci is usually considered fashionable, albeit dandified.
If you're not familiar with him go take a look.

+1

 

[rollinsay]

I've got a question about sizing for the Dundees. I have a pair of McAllister on the 5 last in 10E that fit me well. Would you size the Dundees the same? Thanks!

Any comments?

 

[Wallsy]

Quick question about proper fitting. I just received the Brooks Brothers-branded Strands from the seconds tent sale. They are size 10D. The vamps do not completely close together as they are in many pictures though I see them spread in other pics. Is this a sign that they are too small in width? They otherwise fit well and are comfortable as I walk around on the carpet.

 

[mkevin]

I tried the Boca Ratons before; they feel and look noticeably wider and longer than the Mcallister and Strand. I would say maybe .5 to 1 size longer and .5 wider in width.

Sounds like D will be perfect for me then! Thanks a bunch, I was thinking of going for the E's so you likely just saved me a lot of trouble.

 

[Scottyb06]

Wallsy - you also have to keep in mind the 'slope' of your instep. Example: I have a relatively high instep and so the vamp never closes. When I had wider shoes they were extremely uncomfortable and caused back pain, even though the vamp closed more tightly. You should pay primary attention to the fit first and the vamp second.

 

[donjuan17]



I think it is beneficial to wipe the shoes with a damp cloth, and then apply some Conditioner/Cleaner between steps 1 and 2 above.  Without this step, you are "grinding" grime into your leather when you apply your polish.  At a microscopic level, this has some abrasive effect on the leather fibers.  Also, shoes accumulate stuff during normal wear that is good to remove, and Conditioner/Cleaner is gentle enough to use before each polishing (assuming you don't polish too frequently).  It only costs $4.00 for a bottle that will last a LONG time, and it only adds a few minutes to your process.  

May I ask what kind of conditioner/cleaner you use? Surely not Saphyr.
I ask because I bought one at a local cobbler only to later find out it had a substance that would also waterproof, thus also making it hard for my shoes to breath. I didn't end up using it.

 

[Subutai]

My Tent Sale Banchory seconds. Looks as though the only issue is some stitching!

I apologize for the terrible quality of the photos:







Easily the most comfortable shoe I have ever put on my feet