Really? I use large in my 10.5 3e's and they aren't snug at all. In fact I think I could get away with XLs.
Best bet is to ask a store.
Those look really good. A few more photos like that and I might have to break down and finally enter the world of loafers.
I ordered 5 items and I think shipping was $12 so the code pretty much = free shipping and then some...I really did not do any price shopping so I have no idea if the prices on their site are out of whack or not.