or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc... - Page 3021  

post #45301 of 70737
I believe there is a secret stash in Allison's filing cabinet shhhhh.
post #45302 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by bespoken pa View Post

I believe there is a secret stash in Allison's filing cabinet shhhhh.


Are you serious.......I WANT WALNUT SHELL STRANDS.....:bounce2:

post #45303 of 70737

That's like when I get the Alden irregulars list from TSM......

 

Its the middle of the work day and when that email comes through I drop everything I am doing and dial the # before even looking at the list.....I will shop it while the phone rings......

 

:bounce2::bounce2::bounce2::bounce2::bounce2:

post #45304 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by Watchman1 View Post


Are you serious.......I WANT WALNUT SHELL STRANDS.....bounce2.gif

No not serious I was just messing with Tif. I am convinced that AE is not walnut shell bankrupt just yet. This is based solely on my own illogical conspiracy theory. I have 0 facts to substantiate any of this.
post #45305 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by peppercorn78 View Post
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by CrimmyS View Post

So when you guys says that the Leeds is a shit kicker, does that mean they wouldn't pair with a suit at all?

It seems like most people here like the look of AE's 65 last the most. It's their sleekest right? Just not as good for wide feet like mine.

What exactly is a shit kicker? If you were describing a pair of knock off converse I think I'd understand but any shoe over 200 or 300 in my mind is something I'd care about. Maybe I'm just poor, heh.

Sorry, im originally from San Antonio, so that's a little local vernacular.

Personally, I mean a shoe with some heft. Clunky, robust, and solid. In the best way. Not about quality.

If I were to pair Leeds of MacNeil with a suit, it would probably be with a more casual chunky fall/winter fabric like a heavy tweed or even flannel. Definitely not with anything conservative or formal(ish).

They're great shoes for casual sport coat/trouser pairings, though.

 

More and more, I'm coming to the conclusion that it's the welt and edges that determine how dressy a shoe is.  As in:

 

split-reverse aka storm welt = not dressy

flat welt with wheeled and fudged edges = dressy

post #45306 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jackboot View Post

I'd very much appreciate some opinions advice as I mull over my next shoe purchase. I'm trying to build a complete professional/formal wardrobe.

I currently own a pair of black Park Ave for my most formal wear and a pair of walnut Strands for less formal. I guess this means the major gap in my shoe collection is a pair of darker brown shoes.

I'm hoping to take advantage of the tent sale prices on seconds. Here are the seconds that are available in my size that I'm considering:
- bourbon Fifth Ave @ 199
- brown Fifth Street @ 199
- brown Harrison (Independence Collection) @ 277

The bourbon Fifth Aves may be my top choice. But is bourbon a suitable choice for a more formal brown shoe to wear with suits, or is it too light (i.e., similar to walnut and less formal)? Unfortunately Fifth Aves in brown are not available in my size.

I also really like the Fifth Streets and the brown color is perfect to fill the gap in my dress shoe collection. But I wonder if I I should be considering a pair of brown boots before I have a pair of brown shoes. Opinions?

The brown Harrison is almost identical to the Park Ave which I already own, making me think that may not be the best choice if I want some variety in my small shoe collection. I've also considered buying a pair of black Harrisons and selling my black Park Aves (currently new/unworn). But that would definitely mean that I wouldn't want a second pair of Harrisons in brown.

Any other styles that I should be considering to fill the brown gap in my collection?

Any help is appreciated!

As CrimmyS said, it depends on whether you wear mostly suits or sportcoats and tie.

Having said that, I'm a rule breaker regarding the oxford c. Blucher debate. The latter in brown, like the RL Sanderson, is a versitile shoe for me (but in in coat and tie everyday). Ditto for burgundy shell.

Another option might be a brown McAlister/Jefferson wingtip.

You likely know this but AE bourbon, while great looking, is actually walnot with a lot of burnishing and other post tanning treatment. I wouldn't know how to maintain that color.
post #45307 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by bespoken pa View Post

Not that long ago smile.gif
OK. Maybe one moon ago. Happy? haha
post #45308 of 70737

I'm a size 7D on the MacNeils (7 last), which is the same as my Brannock size, and I was wondering if I would take the same size on the Dundees, which are on the 1 last - can anybody offer up some advice?

 

Also, I've seen how people have been lightening their burgundy Leeds to get a more reddish color and I was wondering if the same thing could be done with the dark brown shell in order to get a more bourbon color?

post #45309 of 70737
^^ For my feet...I am the same size in the MacNeil and the Dundees.
post #45310 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by tifosi View Post

^^ For my feet...I am the same size in the MacNeil and the Dundees.


I have both as well, yep TTS and same size for both.

post #45311 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by halfnhalfnhalf View Post
 

 

I like blobby for everyday shoes.  When I want sleek, I pull out my Carminas.  (Of course, I'm sure others would go sleeker still and would consider Carmina to be blobby.)

 

Agree, there is a time and place for everything.  Some occasions/fits call for clunkier shoes, but when I'm in a suit I'm always reaching for my Carminas.

post #45312 of 70737

How often do these tent sales come around? I'm in need of replacing my black Rockports with something more elegant (5th ave or park ave probably?) but considering I just purchased a pair of Bourbon Lexingtons a couple weeks ago, I want to save up a bit.

 

That is, of course, unless the tent sale is a once a year thing?

post #45313 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by New Shoes1 View Post
 

 

Agree, there is a time and place for everything.  Some occasions/fits call for clunkier shoes, but when I'm in a suit I'm always reaching for my Carminas.


I feel the same way, except I have a brown cordovan Strand that I wear with suits, even worsted's.  Also, the Alden 9015....one of my dressiest.  But, Rain last Carmina's trump them for sleekness.

 

Left to Right:

Brown Cordovan Strand 5 Last-Carmina Short Wing Rain Last-Alden 9015 Hampton Last

 

photo image-18_zps2f828668.jpeg 

post #45314 of 70737

6pm has a pair of Navy Banchory in 12B for $109

post #45315 of 70737

Hey guys,

 

Was wondering if anyone could help me identify an old pair I found on the bay.

 

It's a 5 eyelet cap toe blucher with no medallion. It appears to be in brown or burgundy shell.

 

Numbers inside read

 

10D 94065 12

2754 3648

 

Any help is appreciated.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
This thread is locked  
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc...