Isn't the following most common for AE's signature 5-last?
PA - Black
FA - Dark Brown
Macallister - Merlot
Strand - Walnut
Throw in a pair of boots or some suede shoes and those are probably the only shoes you'll ever need from a minimalist point of view.
Lol I never knew Merlot is that popular. What do you think about Merlot? Almost as formal as Brown? Ok to wear with suit maybe?