or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc... - Page 2243  

post #33631 of 70737
Thanks I signed up for the newsletter last night so hopefully I will get a discount code before to long... not that I need to buy what would be a sixth pair in 2 months but who am I to pass up a deal
post #33632 of 70737

Is this normal for a pair AE's after about 25-30 uses?

 

Defect?

 

 

Normal or not, these are going back to Nordstrom's today.

post #33633 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by deeselcyde View Post
 

Is this normal for a pair AE's after about 25-30 uses?

 

Defect?

 

 

 

Normal or not, these are going back to Nordstrom's today.

I would say that is very abnormal for any pair of decent shoes, including AEs.  

 

Did you buy them as seconds?  Did you get them very wet and not allow them to dry for an extended period (not sure if water damage would cause that to happen, but I'm sure someone on here would be)?

post #33634 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by random-adam View Post


I do this regularly with burgundy shell Daltons and am happy with the way it looks. Wife and I spent a few hours in Georgetown (DC) a couple weekends ago; in every store the sales folks were all "man, nice kicks" and "that's the reason why boot season is fantastic". All the attention forces me to keep them even more brushed and clean than usual. No photos at the moment, unfortunately.

I'd like to see this look if someone has pictures.  Been trying to pull it off to no avail. Wondering if my jeans are too long for this look...

post #33635 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by jungleroller View Post
 

Got the good phone call from Allison yesterday!  Got back to the office this afternoon and shoe giggidy!!

 

The color (Brown Shell Cordovan) is a little flat out of the box but I'm hoping with some TLC these will be a great addition to my collection.

 

They are the "Players" Model.  Independence lining and insole and outsole.  Brown flat welt with wheeled edges. Transparent Brown edge dressing.  

 

I'll try to get some better pics (fluorescent at work kinda crappy)  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I'm glad I pulled a last minute change and went up a width based on how narrow I heard these can be.  

Is that bowing on the right shoe?

post #33636 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by tjyoung View Post
 

I'd like to see this look if someone has pictures.  Been trying to pull it off to no avail. Wondering if my jeans are too long for this look...


I would not stuff them in. I would just fold/roll up the jeans 2-3 times depending on the length. It should be more than enough.


I think stuffing jeans into boots like the dalton looks silly because they aren't calf length. I do this when I wear 'skinny' jeans with frye boots that go halfway up my calf.

post #33637 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by random-adam View Post


Mine took me to the Frye store a couple weeks ago to help pick her out a new pair. smile.gif

The saleswoman, after successfully matching her up with some boots, turned her sights on me -- but those things only come in one width... and my fancy shell Daltons were perhaps a little bit intimidating in that den of distressed cowhide.


I dunno, these are pretty handsome frye boots.

 

 

AE needs to make something like this.

post #33638 of 70737

^

 

I agree. That's sort of what I was thinking with my Shaker Heights MTO, substituting leather for the tweed.

post #33639 of 70737

They also don't make the shaker heights in black. I have three tweed blazers that I wear pretty regularly through the winter. The brown ones would be nice for a pairing methinks but $$$.

Spending money on having jackets altered for now. Heh.

post #33640 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by deeselcyde View Post
 

Is this normal for a pair AE's after about 25-30 uses?

 

Defect?

 

 

Normal or not, these are going back to Nordstrom's today.

The soles look very abused to me. This could pretty much only happen if you wear them in the rain.

post #33641 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by ridethecliche View Post

Is that bowing on the right shoe?

Not when they're on. It has a reinforced top line with the brogueing so I'm not worried about that.
post #33642 of 70737

Do AE cordovan shoes fit tighter in the same size vs calf?

 

I am looking at getting a pair of cordovan Strands but just want to be sure I should buy the same size as my McAllisters

post #33643 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by Burzan View Post
 

Do AE cordovan shoes fit tighter in the same size vs calf?

 

I am looking at getting a pair of cordovan Strands but just want to be sure I should buy the same size as my McAllisters

 

I find the cordovan version to be either slightly looser or the same.  Good luck!  

post #33644 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by bucksfan View Post

I find the cordovan version to be either slightly looser or the same.  Good luck!  

Agreed
post #33645 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by deeselcyde View Post
 

Is this normal for a pair AE's after about 25-30 uses?

 

Defect?

 

 

Normal or not, these are going back to Nordstrom's today.

 

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by cincikid View Post
 

The soles look very abused to me. This could pretty much only happen if you wear them in the rain.

 

 

Leather soles will wear out quicker in wet environments, but that doesn't preclude them from being worn in the rain.  The sole will wear quicker because of the soft wet leather.  You should be able to wear shoes a good bit in the rain before the soles wear out, unless you are walking very long distances on wet concrete.  Even if he has been wearing them in the rain, what I see in those photos doesn't necessarily explain what's going on.  Soles are lock stitched on, which means the threads are looped together in the stitch hole so that the threads don't separate even after the bottom is abraded by wear:

 

 

The depth of the loop or "lock" can be adjusted and is typically set to be 2/3 or so up into the hole from the bottom, so that the soles don't separate even when the part of the thread that is exposed to the ground gets worn away.  Additionally, the exposed part of the thread is provided a little bit of protection by cutting a groove in the sole for the stitches to nest in.  Also, the soles are cemented on before they are stitched, which can help keep things attached as well.

 

In his photos above, the stitch groove is still present, which means the stitches have worn away and separated before the lock stitch should have been compromised.  This is unusual, and would be very frustrating.  In other words, the "theory" behind stitched soles has failed in this instance.  Does that mean that AE or Nordstrom has to do something about it?  Not necessarily, since it is pretty much impossible to prove that they have only been worn a few times, and that they weren't abused (like plucking the stitches out from the top).  It almost looks like the thread has been pulled, in a similar way that you can pull a thread on an article of clothing, which can start a domino effect of unraveling.  However, that's impossible with a lock stitch.  I'm not saying that the OP has done this.  I'm simply saying that this is unusual.  I won't be surprised if they take the shoes back or repair them at no cost, since both companies are known for stellar customer service.  If it has been a completely natural occurrence, I would personally classify it as a defect, and keep my fingers crossed that they'll fix it or exchange it.

 

Don't expect this to happen to your shoes simply from wearing them in the rain though.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
This thread is locked  
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc...