or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc... - Page 1917  

post #28741 of 70737

Ok, here is a good pic of my new $299 Walnut Shell Cordovan Macneils. Be jealous SF members, be very jealous... :) 

 

AppleMark

 

Last night I did one application of Reno-Mat, then a liberal application of Venetian Creme. As the GOP Shoe Guy, I don't do many liberal things, but I gave it a good coating... I am very pleased with the results. There was a lot of brown shoe creme on these that came off during my treatment.

 

AppleMark

 

Here is a comparison with my MTO Walnut Shell Macneils with a natural welt. It is nice to have a natural and brown welt. The natural is to casual for suits. The brown welt is perfect for a business or more formal attire, and the natural for blue jeans or a more casual business setting. 

 

The only knock I have against these is that the eyelets do not match up perfectly, on the seconds and on my MTO. You can see in the pic above that the natural welt shoes, the eyelets leave you with crooked laces. On the brown welt shoes the right shoe eyeltes are straight, but the left is a bit off... While having these on, this is not so noticeable that it is a deal breaker. I love both my Walnut Cordovan.

post #28742 of 70737
^^ looks great! Now that you have both you may want to consider adding brass eyelets to the natural welt pair. Since you will be wearing them casually I think it would look great
post #28743 of 70737

I just received my second pair of AE in the mail yesterday, walnut Dalton's, but there seems to be some defects on them.  There is a  crease on the side of one shoe and also a black scuff mark. What do you guys think? These are not factory seconds. The rep that sold them to me said they had to build them since they didn't have my size.   Should I ask for a new pair?  I received another pair of these about a month ago that were the wrong size, and they did not have either of these issues. Appreciate your input!  Thanks

 

 

post #28744 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by rydenfan View Post

^^ looks great! Now that you have both you may want to consider adding brass eyelets to the natural welt pair. Since you will be wearing them casually I think it would look great

 

 

That's great advice!  A decent cobbler can put brass eyelets in there, and perhaps if you change to lighter coloured laces too?  If you're really bold, maybe something contrasting like blue.  Would give an overall feel totally different to the other pair then.

post #28745 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by GOP Shoe Guy View Post

Ok, here is a good pic of my new $299 Walnut Shell Cordovan Macneils. Be jealous SF members, be very jealous... smile.gif 
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
AppleMark

Last night I did one application of Reno-Mat, then a liberal application of Venetian Creme. As the GOP Shoe Guy, I don't do many liberal things, but I gave it a good coating... I am very pleased with the results. There was a lot of brown shoe creme on these that came off during my treatment.

AppleMark


Here is a comparison with my MTO Walnut Shell Macneils with a natural welt. It is nice to have a natural and brown welt. The natural is to casual for suits. The brown welt is perfect for a business or more formal attire, and the natural for blue jeans or a more casual business setting. 

The only knock I have against these is that the eyelets do not match up perfectly, on the seconds and on my MTO. You can see in the pic above that the natural welt shoes, the eyelets leave you with crooked laces. On the brown welt shoes the right shoe eyeltes are straight, but the left is a bit off... While having these on, this is not so noticeable that it is a deal breaker. I love both my Walnut Cordovan.

wow, these look awesome. I am loving both pair. Great score, and great thinking going back to find the seconds! Congrats!
post #28746 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by GOP Shoe Guy View Post
 

Ok, here is a good pic of my new $299 Walnut Shell Cordovan Macneils. Be jealous SF members, be very jealous... :)

 

AppleMark

 

Last night I did one application of Reno-Mat, then a liberal application of Venetian Creme. As the GOP Shoe Guy, I don't do many liberal things, but I gave it a good coating... I am very pleased with the results. There was a lot of brown shoe creme on these that came off during my treatment.

 

AppleMark

 

Here is a comparison with my MTO Walnut Shell Macneils with a natural welt. It is nice to have a natural and brown welt. The natural is to casual for suits. The brown welt is perfect for a business or more formal attire, and the natural for blue jeans or a more casual business setting.

 

The only knock I have against these is that the eyelets do not match up perfectly, on the seconds and on my MTO. You can see in the pic above that the natural welt shoes, the eyelets leave you with crooked laces. On the brown welt shoes the right shoe eyeltes are straight, but the left is a bit off... While having these on, this is not so noticeable that it is a deal breaker. I love both my Walnut Cordovan.

 

 

It looks like the Reno Mat pulled off quite a bit of creme. They lightened up nicely and almost match your other pair. Nice work and congrats again!

post #28747 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by kcip View Post
 

I just received my second pair of AE in the mail yesterday, walnut Dalton's, but there seems to be some defects on them.  There is a  crease on the side of one shoe and also a black scuff mark. What do you guys think? These are not factory seconds. The rep that sold them to me said they had to build them since they didn't have my size.   Should I ask for a new pair?  I received another pair of these about a month ago that were the wrong size, and they did not have either of these issues. Appreciate your input!  Thanks

 


 

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

 

 

The wrinkle I would not worry about - you will add wrinkles the first time you wear them.  The black polish or sole edge mark may come off with a little TLC, but may not.  I'd give it a shot with a damp cloth and a brush first.  Then make a decision.  

 

 

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by GOP Shoe Guy View Post
 

Ok, here is a good pic of my new $299 Walnut Shell Cordovan Macneils. Be jealous SF members, be very jealous... :) 

 

 

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

AppleMark

 

Last night I did one application of Reno-Mat, then a liberal application of Venetian Creme. As the GOP Shoe Guy, I don't do many liberal things, but I gave it a good coating... I am very pleased with the results. There was a lot of brown shoe creme on these that came off during my treatment.

 

AppleMark

 

 

Here is a comparison with my MTO Walnut Shell Macneils with a natural welt. It is nice to have a natural and brown welt. The natural is to casual for suits. The brown welt is perfect for a business or more formal attire, and the natural for blue jeans or a more casual business setting. 

 

The only knock I have against these is that the eyelets do not match up perfectly, on the seconds and on my MTO. You can see in the pic above that the natural welt shoes, the eyelets leave you with crooked laces. On the brown welt shoes the right shoe eyeltes are straight, but the left is a bit off... While having these on, this is not so noticeable that it is a deal breaker. I love both my Walnut Cordovan.

 

Real beauties, GOP - congrats on finding your seconds!  

 

Today: burgundy shell Randolphs

 

post #28748 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by tifosi View Post
 

 

 

It looks like the Reno Mat pulled off quite a bit of creme. They lightened up nicely and almost match your other pair. Nice work and congrats again!

 

Can you explain why you'd use the Reno Mat on the new shells?  Was it to lighten them, pull off excess polish, etc?  The end result looks amazing, but would you do this for all new shell shoes, or did you use that method for a specific purpose?

 

I'm waiting for my first shell AE's to arrive, and thought of the 'wipe-down' and brush like crazy method, but your post intrigues me.  

post #28749 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by sazon View Post

I don't always follow this thread very closely but I'm sure glad I did this week. I was able to score the Park Ave in shell. The shoe has some creasing (was obviously tried on), but for $299 I'm not going to complain. Thanks to all for the heads up on Sunday!

These arrived quickly as they just happened to be at an AE store 7 miles from my house!
  Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)


 

Very Nice, Sazon -  I ordered the same shoes - I hope mine look as nice as yours!  

post #28750 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by slimjohnil6 View Post

Can you explain why you'd use the Reno Mat on the new shells?  Was it to lighten them, pull off excess polish, etc?  The end result looks amazing, but would you do this for all new shell shoes, or did you use that method for a specific purpose?

I'm waiting for my first shell AE's to arrive, and thought of the 'wipe-down' and brush like crazy method, but your post intrigues me.  
I hope the OP replies as well, but I believe he thought that the factory went a little heavy on the creme polish. He wanted to remove the excess. It is probably just a quicker way to do what the mac method eventually does. I have mac'd my Cambridge probably 5 times by now and I still get significant polish removal. Although last night I felt like I had quite a breakthough and they are really starting to look nice. They are beginning to have a nice even shine as opposed to the splotchy appearance they have had.
post #28751 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by bucksfan View Post

The wrinkle I would not worry about - you will add wrinkles the first time you wear them.  The black polish or sole edge mark may come off with a little TLC, but may not.  I'd give it a shot with a damp cloth and a brush first.  Then make a decision.  




Real beauties, GOP - congrats on finding your seconds!  

Today: burgundy shell Randolphs


Your Randolphs look absolutely fantastic, Bucks! Great shine on them with a great finish. Bravo. I know you had more to do with the shine than the finish, haha. I honestly thought they were Aldens at first glance. Spectacular.
post #28752 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by slimjohnil6 View Post
 

 

Can you explain why you'd use the Reno Mat on the new shells?  Was it to lighten them, pull off excess polish, etc?  The end result looks amazing, but would you do this for all new shell shoes, or did you use that method for a specific purpose?

 

I'm waiting for my first shell AE's to arrive, and thought of the 'wipe-down' and brush like crazy method, but your post intrigues me.  

I used Reno on them because there was a ton of creme on them. Removing that creme got it down closer to the raw shell, which gives a much deeper appearance that a thick layer of brown creme. I did not reno the ones with the natural welt, there was hardly any creme on them. I do not do that with all of my shells, just on the ones that are loaded with a product.

post #28753 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by mimo View Post
 

 

 

That's great advice!  A decent cobbler can put brass eyelets in there, and perhaps if you change to lighter coloured laces too?  If you're really bold, maybe something contrasting like blue.  Would give an overall feel totally different to the other pair then.

 

I have about a dozen different pairs of colorful laces that I mix and match quite often. Blue and purple both look great with walnut shoes. I will give some consideration to the brass eyelets. I 100% agree on the colored laces.

post #28754 of 70737
Quote:
Originally Posted by GOP Shoe Guy View Post

I have about a dozen different pairs of colorful laces that I mix and match quite often. Blue and purple both look great with walnut shoes. I will give some consideration to the brass eyelets. I 100% agree on the colored laces.
GOP: I would personally leave the eyelets alone, but I 100% agree on the laces as well.
post #28755 of 70737
Ordered Burgundy shell Grayson, and found an outlet with a Truffle shell McAllister, cant wait to get those
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
This thread is locked  
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc...