I'd also be interested in info on the fit of McGraws, particularly compared to 5-last shoes like PAs and 5As.
Also any comparison between McGraws and Westchesters as far as fit or style?
Oh, and, In the non-loafer arena, how do the 4-last Long Branches fit compared to the 5-last shoes?
I have a pair of McGraw Shells and a pair of Strands, both in 7E. The Strands definitely fit better and I eventually put tongue pads into the McGraws as they were a bit lose. I'd be curious to try on a pair of McGraws in a smaller size.