What is the email address here and are closeouts labeled on the size list?
tietherope, you looking Suede or Brown Calf?
After reviewing fitting advice in this thread, I think I should go with an 8.5D. There is only one of these available and it is in Suede.
Now the question is... would I rather have an unlined suede chukka with a leather sole (Amok) or a lined suede chukka with a rubber sole (Malvern)?
Did you size down on the Elgin? It's been talked about on this thread before but I found them to run a little larger than calf versions on the same last. I went with the same size in the Elgin as in McAllister and the Elgin are definitely a little looser. I can get away with it because the McAllister are a little snug. For me anyway, I think I'd size down 1/2 on the Elgin but keep the width.