Go with the one with more white. I ordered the same shoe with red instead of the blue (same sole). Same amount of white as yours with more white. Though I did add a white tongue. Really makes the laces pop. There isn't a doubt in my mind that these will be worn as a casual shoe. Chinos and jeans. The only suit I will wear mine with is my seersucker. This is not a dress shoe. Very fun though, and I can't wait for mine to arrive.
Good feedback. I also like the brown welt which makes it a little better for going our for drinks in the evening and not just day wear. I have the Lubbock with the natural welt and it is quite light.
By the way, did you order your normal size?