Yeah, I was gonna ask for recommendations on AE belts so I have something that matches really well.
Also, I just realized that I'll have the right polish, so I might polish a belt for the first time in my life. Then again, that might stain my pants, huh? Maybe just use Conditioner/Cleaner.
If AE doesn't come out with a bourbon belt, I think the next best option is to take your shoes to a local Nordstrom and find a matching belt. Nordstrom has a nice selection of high quality leather belts.