Originally Posted by rennavate
I'm a 40 chest now, just measured. Chest's increased as I've been working out over the last few months.
Still not sure whether I'm going to keep it or not...
It looks good, man. The XL would look good too, or if you were a 42 in a L, it would look good. Those Fisherman turtlenecks are the most forgiving fit ever, it's the combination of the heavy knit, the stretch, and the shoulder space. Do what feels right.
Don't sweat the dropped shoulder comments (a XS would still have a dropped shoulder) or the full zip comments (no hate, but who decided the greatest sweater ever needed more late 90s Banana Republic?)