As a person that came over from superfuture, I never thought that I would find a group that shared my rare love for classic shaving. I have not read this whole thread yet, but any of you members of badgerandblade.com, or shavemyface.com?
-Merkur HD Double Edge
-Colonel Conk Badger Brush
-Decleor latherless shave cream, Trufitt & Hill 1805 or Lime, Florena, and I have a years worth (literally, at least, of samples I wrote companies for)
-Anthony Logistics Astringent Aftershave (as a toner)
-Brave Soldier Code Blue aftershave
-ohh, for a wash pre-shave I use either Anthony Logistics or if I need a scrub, Molten Brown at the moment.
Cheers, and if you have not tried a real cream/soap and a DE Razor, you owe it to yourself.