I double-cuff (over once, then over again), but have been doing so long before I knew what selvage is (in fact, I don't really know what selvage is now). Some people think the cuffs are unusual, but apparently I look like someone who should be cuffing his jeans - squirrelly pale skinny trashy guy with sideburns and tattoos - so I'm told it isn't too jarring. I also wear my current project jeans (APC NS) skinnier than the average person, which is approximately like taking more Eucharist than the average mullah.
I do get compliments but I suspect it's more because of decent fit and the "darkness" of the raw denim than anything else. Most jeans around here are sack-assed baby-blue or horrible washes.
The "raw denim" concept baffles one of the receptionists at the tattoo shop, who was completely mystified by the concept of not washing the jeans during the extended "break-in" period. She clandestinely put her number in my cell phone even though I've been married for almost 12 years, though, so I guess she isn't overly freaked out by my filfiness.