Not sure I like it in black.
OK in tan
But no otter green
I just got a mackinaw cruiser as well. I'm normally a 39 or 40 size chest and the 36 fits fine with a sweater. These things are enormous, so I really recommend sizing down unless you plan to wear a live preserver or something underneath.
Arg. Killing me with that temptation. I love that jacket. Tried it on in the store - seems to run large, at least for me, YRMV. Forest all day baby.