Something far les edgy, that's for sure. I like wearing black, and I like wearing a biker jacket; but I don't have the wardrobe to fully support that yet. Hell, I think a ToJ bball would be a nice replacement (it's more casual, looks better with blue jeans than a black leather does). However, I'm always interested to see if anyone might suggest something that hasn't come up on my radar yet.
Leather would be nice, but I'm open to suggestions for something wool as well.
This is a strange sentiment, considering you own jeans, sneakers, and if I recall, a boot or two. Keep the MDR. It looks good. You'll be glad you did in 3 weeks when you regret selling it and want to wear it again.