Recent Images In This Thread
- topicAdvicetagged by LA Guy, 4/2/15
- categoryDenimtagged by LA Guy, 5/3/15
- categoryDenim Outerweartagged by LA Guy, 5/3/15
- categoryDenim Shirtstagged by LA Guy, 5/3/15
- topicFashiontagged by SYSTEM, 9/10/11
- categoryJacketstagged by SYSTEM, 7/21/11
- categoryJeanstagged by SYSTEM, 7/21/11
- categoryLong Sleeve Shirtstagged by SYSTEM, 7/21/11
- brandMaison Martin Margielatagged by LA Guy, 10/8/13
- brandMaison Martin Margiela 1tagged by LA Guy, 10/8/13More
- brandMaison Martin Margiela 10tagged by LA Guy, 10/8/13
- brandMaison Martin Margiela 11tagged by LA Guy, 10/8/13
- brandMaison Martin Margiela 14tagged by LA Guy, 10/8/13
- brandMaison Martin Margiela 22tagged by LA Guy, 10/8/13
- categoryScarvestagged by SYSTEM, 7/21/11
- brandStephan Schneidertagged by LA Guy, 10/8/13
- topicStyletagged by SYSTEM, 9/10/11
Related Forum Threads
- Difference between MMM Avant Première and Première Sneakers Last post on 3/24/15 at 2:36pm in Streetwear and Denim
- THE AMI Paris Alexendre Mattiussi THREAD Last post on 7/5/15 at 12:08pm in Streetwear and Denim
- Does it exist? a jeans or denim line that is really high-end and exclusive that could be... Last post on 6/23/14 at 10:41pm in Classic Menswear
- XS/29/8 MJK, Gitman, N&F and more Last post on 6/2/11 at 9:11pm in FS: Streetwear & Denim (Archive)
- HOF: What Are You Wearing Right Now - Part IV (starting May 2014) Last post on Today at 9:06 pm in Classic Menswear
The Styleforum Brief: May 2015
Last edited: 5/7/15
- How to Wear a Blazer and Jeans this Spring (Hint: Jeans Are Not...Last edited: 5/11/15
- What I Learned from Slim DenimLast edited: 12/21/14
- Streetstyle: The Best Pictures From Pitti Uomo 88Last edited: 7/20/15
- Tokyo Diaries, Day 2: Quick Photo Dump!Last edited: 6/22/15
- Andrew Lock
- The Armoury
- Buttons 'n' Threads
- David Fin
- David Reeves Bespoke
- Drinkwater's Cambridge
- Equus Leather
- Exquisite Trimmings
- A Fine Pair of Shoes
- Franco Ercole Bespoke
- Geil Mode
- Gentlemen's Footwear
- Gordon Yao, Hong Kong
- The Hanger Project
- Henry Carter Neckwear
- Howard Yount
- John Elliott + Co
- Kent Wang
- Khaki's of Carmel
- Luxire Custom Clothing
- M Classic 101
- Meermin Mallorca
- Need Supply Co.
- No Man Walks Alone
- Oak Room
- Oscar Hunt
- Paul Evans
- Percy Ivor
- Portland Dry Goods
- Proper Cloth
- S.E.H Kelly
- Self Edge
- Spier & Mackay
- Suspension Point
- Taylor Stitch
- Temple of jawnz
- Thurston Bros.
- Uncle Otis
- Virtual Clotheshorse
- Wolf vs. Goat
- Wrong Weather
- Yellow Hook Necktie
- Zampa Di Gallina
Random fashion thoughts - Page 4869post #73021 of 1090542/5/13 at 6:59pm
Styleforum Top Pickspost #73022 of 1090542/5/13 at 7:45pmpost #73023 of 1090542/5/13 at 10:12pmpost #73024 of 1090542/5/13 at 10:25pmpost #73025 of 1090542/6/13 at 6:08amQuote:Originally Posted by pickpackpockpuck
I recently looked up a few of Nicholas Kristof's sweatshop pieces again and thought I would post a couple here in case people haven't seen them. Kristof regularly praises sweatshops and thinks they should be promoted rather than maligned. Have a look here and here, for instance.The TL;DNR version is this: sweatshops are good for people in developing countries because the work is much better (steadier, safer) than doing things like sifting through garbage dumps.
The argument always struck me as simplistic. Maybe working in a sweatshop is better than collecting trash to recycle, but factory workers in the developing world are often mistreated in other ways and the work still isn't good in and of itself (there are plenty of takedowns of Kristof's argument, like this one).
I started thinking about this because I'm reading Half the Sky, by Kristof and Sheryl WuDunn, his wife. It talks a lot about the sex trade in places like India, and while many girls are kidnapped and trafficked into the sex trade, many others choose to become sex workers because they're just plain desperate. It's that or starve. And when you read about the psychological and physical abuse these women endure, you start to wonder if a sweatshop might not be better. Yes, plenty of sweatshops do awful things to their "employees" (that word is a euphemism here), like beat them and force abortions on pregnant workers. But plenty also just pay badly and make their employees work long hours. In a case like that, it's hard not to think it would be better for a woman to work there than deal with bad pay/long hours but doing so as a sex worker subject to regular violence and disease. Lesser of two evils, but it's still hard to justify.
Of course this would all be moot if sweatshops paid fair wages and offered healthcare and generally treated their workers like humans, but that's obviously not happening anytime soon. I don't know. In the meantime is it still better for a person to work for 15-hour days for $1.50 in a stifling but shaded room rather than sell their bodies or have to climb through rotting garbage in full sun all day? Sucks.
edit: I assume it's obvious why this is relevant to the forum. I imagine 99% of the people looking at this own/are wearing an article of clothing that was made in the developing world, and that implies a strong likelihood that it was made at a sweatshop. So when you see that "Made in India" tag or "Made in Thailand" tag, is it more ethical to buy or not?
Having been to a few manufacturing facilities myself, I would say the mental aspect of the work is much more crippling than the physical. You essentially perform the same mind numbing task repeatedly every day for long hours. An example would be sitting on a chair and applying a barcode onto a box for 10 hours a day. Like LAGuy mention, the structure of processing is piecework and you're just a small cog within the machine. Witnessing this really makes you appreciate how lucky you are and what life you're born into.post #73026 of 1090542/6/13 at 6:24ampost #73027 of 1090542/6/13 at 6:26ampost #73028 of 1090542/6/13 at 6:31ampost #73029 of 1090542/6/13 at 7:53ampost #73030 of 1090542/6/13 at 8:14ampost #73031 of 1090542/6/13 at 8:19amQuote:Originally Posted by LA Guy
Incidentally, you don't have to leave the US to see crappy factories. It's easy to find them in LA.
And it's not just cheap goods either. A lot of high end clothing is made using piecework. Do you know how long it takes to make a handknit sweater? Or shape an finish a hat? And how much do you think knitters and hatters are making per piece? And btw, those workers get no healthcare either. And if they make enough mistakes, or don't work fast enough, they are making minimum wage or less, sometimes.
Same in NYC. Though I think the "crappiness" is on a whole different level in a sweatshop in a developing country compared to a factory in the US. But then that's assuming the US factory we're comparing to is legit, not some underground joint set up in Chinatown where it's basically slave labor, which of course also happens.post #73032 of 1090542/6/13 at 8:46ampost #73033 of 1090542/6/13 at 8:53ampost #73034 of 1090542/6/13 at 8:59am
This thread is locked
- Random fashion thoughts
Styleforum Top Picks
- How to Wear a Blazer and Jeans this Spring (Hint: Jeans Are Not...
- › **The Official Shoe Care Thread: Tutorials, Photos, etc.** 5 minutes ago
- › The Official RRL Thread 6 minutes ago
- › The Watch Appreciation Thread 10 minutes ago
- › What would you wear today? 12 minutes ago
- › Mod to Suedehead 13 minutes ago
- › Australian Members 21 minutes ago
- › Unfunded Liabilities: a/k/a The Cloth Thread 26 minutes ago
- › Compared to my friends, I'm failing in my career. How do I get back... 30 minutes ago
- › Casper Mattress 30 minutes ago
- › Kit chen Design In Glasgow Area UK 32 minutes ago
- › Carmina for Epaulet Grey Suede Steinbeck Boot by Patek
- › Human Scales Denny Suede Double Monkstraps by Mrvaerk
- › Brathwait - The classic slim wrist watch by Mrvaerk
- › Ps Paul Smith Laced shoes by yucaseca
- › Tom Ford FT5237 Eyeglasses Color 098 by Mrvaerk
- › Irish Setter Men's 838 Wingshooter 6" Waterproof Lace-up... by seanhorween
- › Borsa Long sleeve shirt by techstyles
- › Neil Barrett - LEATHER TROUSERS by newway
- › Mandarina Duck City Messenger by josh89
- › Quoddy True Penny Loafer by ppith
- › Styleforum Visits Blue Blue Japan
- › Styleforum Eats its Way Through Tokyo
- › David Looks Back at Pitti Uomo 88
- › Streetstyle: The Best Pictures From Pitti...
- › The Styleforum Brief: July, 2015
- › Carmina Shoes Presents: Five Shoes for Five...
- › Help! I need a suit for a wedding!
- › What I learned from my own wedding day, and...
- › Look nice, Dammit: Why you should care - and...
- › Tokyo Diaries, Day 4: Epic Tokyo Photo Dump -...