Have you not seen Inapt? Their peacoats are shorter, and were (are?) rather popular (at least on the internets). I really don't get the hate for the second set of pockets and i'd assume that some boxiness was intended, not everything is meant to be extremely slim (i'd say outerwear is a prime example of when slim may look off). Also, correct me if i'm wrong, but i'd assume 30oz wool doesn't drape/move as well as a much lighter wool, even one so heavy as 24oz as he specifies is used in US Navy peacoats or whatever. Anyway, not my cup of tea, but I don't understand your criticisms.