What shoe care brands do you use?

I have used both Kiwi and Saphir brand wax polish and polishing cream. Also use Saphir Creme Universelle Leather Balm to condition the leather. Honestly the difference is not that big between any of the brands be they Melitonians, Kiwi, Saphir or what. Some would argue that there is but for me they all work. More importantly is how you are polishing the shoes. Good technique goes a long way. Did you heat the wax prior to using, are you applying in small areas and in a smooth even layer etc. Also invest in a decent brush. Otherwise Kiwi should be fine. Becareful with the creams though as they darken the shoes a bit (but great if you're trying to create some patinas)

I would order some Saphir from Franco's in Richmond.

Kiwi and AE.

My cobbler recommended Meltonian. I use it and find it works well but I can't speak for it's long run performance.

I'm a little pampered and am fortunate enough to have a maid that polishes my shoes, so this is an unbiased review from someone that knows nothing about brand appeal.

I've given her John Lobb and Bally polishes, and she says she prefers Kiwi!

Saphir for the smell, Kiwi for scuff coverage/shine.

As much as I want to like Saphir, I secretly think Kiwi does a better job at what it's meant to do.

Up to you, really. You should be able to keep the color of the shoe close regardless of how much shine you prefer. Try using a polish just slightly lighter than the shoe to keep it from darkening. You can always shine up a matte shoe, or let a shiny one dull down, so it's not permanent either way.

Why not get Allen-Edmonds Premium Shoe Polish in Walnut? It will perfectly match your shoes, and being a mix of wax and cream, it should complement the semi-matte finish of most A-E calfskins. The only downside is that at $9 for a tube, it's kind of expensive compared to Kiwi. I suspect, though, that Kiwi's Tan polish would work pretty well with your A-Es in walnut.

I use Kiwi, Meltonian, and AE.

JayJay,

Have you been here yet?
Landwerlen Leather Co
(317) 636-8300
365 S Illinois St (across from the bus station)
Indianapolis, IN 46225

Here's a review:

Great source of leather and shoe repair supplies

Shopping at Landwerlen is like stepping into the past. It is a true speciality store which carries leather, leathercraft supplies and tools, and shoe making/repair supplies. Their prices are reasonable and the staff members are knowlegable. For small leather projects, their scrap bins are a great source of unusual pieces at bargain prices. Don't be scared by the dark "historic" building; this place is a gem.

____________________________________________________________________________

I use Meltonian, Kelly, and Lincoln from Landwerlen. I just received some Saphir from Franco's.

Saphir and KIWI

Woly for cremes Kiwi for polish