Styleforum › Forums › General › Entertainment and Culture › What makes a sport a sport in your mind?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

What makes a sport a sport in your mind? - Page 7

post #91 of 97
Quote:
Originally Posted by mafoofan View Post
Balls.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark from Plano View Post
This would exclude Women's ice hockey.

Maybe not. I've seen some rather burly women hockey players....

I'm just sayin'
post #92 of 97
WINNER


Quote:
Originally Posted by denning View Post
This argument comes down to one of semantics and definitional categorization. I believe that a "sport" requires a corporeal opponent against whom you physically compete through interaction. This would include soccer, baseball, basketball, hockey, football, volleyball, tennis, etc. where there are teams or individuals directly competing against another team individual in a one on one fashion.

Then there are athletic competitions. This is where you are competing but success is measured by your actions in comparison to others, not through direct interactive competition with others. Running, cycling, skiing, biathlon, swimming, gymnastics, figure skating, diving, equestrian, racing of any sort (MotoGP, Nascar, Formula 1). This also includes those activities that are judged. This distinction does not in my mind denigrate or belittle those competitions or those who engage in them. But I believe this is where the distinction lies.

Then there are those activities which fall somewhere in the middle and defy categorization pursuant to my guidelines. These include things like boxing and MMA which is a combination of my categories in that there is corporeal adversarial competition, but there is also scoring by judges. Then there are others which fall under the definitional categorization of a sport, such as table tennis, which I just have a tough ime classifying as a sport. This seems to me to be a game.

This leads to the last categorization, games of skill. This would include things like chess, poker. Golf is sort of in this category, and sort of an athletic competition.

This is not a definitive description, but I would say these are decent guidelines.
post #93 of 97
Quote:
Originally Posted by greekonomist View Post
What exactly do you think this rules out?
Not much really as you can gamble on pretty much anything. Just bringing it up as a qualification for sporthood.
post #94 of 97
Quote:
Originally Posted by gdl203 View Post
But dominos and croquet = sports, right?

No & I guess

Quote:
Originally Posted by JD_May View Post
Fail.

Any criteria that can classify competitive activities that require one to be in absolute peak physical condition as NOT a sport, but qualify golf (and arguably darts, lawn bowling, etc) as a sport, is a complete lose.

Nope. Darts could be considered a sport. Golf is a sport. I think there's the perception that a competition is somewhat lacking some level of "toughness" that sports have. I don't think that's the case, both can be hard, mentally and physically challenging but only a sport gives you a "sporting chance".
post #95 of 97
Quote:
Originally Posted by JacobJacob View Post
This is what good sport is all about <assorted rockclimbing pics>
while I am far from denying the awesomeness of this, what exactly makes it a sport?
post #96 of 97
as long as players of said competition can get hurt and badly injured whitin the realm of said competition, I'll say it's a sport.
post #97 of 97
Chessboxing is the only real sport. Also, "can get hurt" is such a stupid qualification. You can get hurt walking down stairs in your house. Think of a better way to make physical exertion necessary.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Entertainment and Culture
Styleforum › Forums › General › Entertainment and Culture › What makes a sport a sport in your mind?