Styleforum › Forums › Lifestyle › Health & Body › Yet Another Shaving Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Yet Another Shaving Thread

post #1 of 16
Thread Starter 
First off, apologies for starting off yet another shaving thread. I've read through most of the previous ones in detail, but a lot of the recommended products like crabtree and evelyn brushes, Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood shaving cream, etc, don't appear to be carried anymore.

I'm returning to the states this week for vacation and I want to get started in DE shaving. Actually I already tried last December when I got a Christmas gift of a DE razor and a supply of Proraso products, but it always took me 45 minutes to shave and Proraso felt like it turned my skin into sandpaper (maybe drying it out? I don't really know why, but I just did not like it). I eventually gave it up. I started out strong but I had too many painful, bloody, shaves, and my ingrown hair problem on my neck just seemed to be more aggravated.

I want to give it another go, and I need to buy it all in one shot since I'm only in-country for two weeks, and money IS an object.

I need a brush, shaving cream/soap (to be honest, I don't really understand the difference), and maybe some pre-shave oil (Does it really help that much? I've just been using olive oil, and I like it fine), or after shave (usually I use a drug-store brand after shave balm with moisturizing properties. I'm open to suggestion).

I'm thinking about starting here:

http://westcoastshaving.com/index.ph...products_id=92

Then maybe get the eshave travel kit, or the mini-kit to try different fragrances of their shaving cream.

I already have a big sampler pack of blades and the DE razor itself. Taylor of Old Bond Street-Sandalwood seems highly recommended on SF, but they don't have the tub anymore. I can only find a tube on Amazon. Is it the same thing?: http://www.amazon.com/Taylor-Old-Bon...ecc_rvi_cart_2

Thoughts? Advice? Anyone had similar trials and tribulations trying to make the switch?
post #2 of 16
Thread Starter 
It also could be worth mentioning that I have pretty sensitive skin.
post #3 of 16
If you have sensitive skin, then your best bet is to try products with as little fragrance as possible. re: eShave, I've only tried eShave's avocado/linden soap but it's fantastic. Proraso would be out of the question for you. Also recommend Provence Sante's Verlaine soap.

Although, you might do well with just the hot towel treatment and shaving using just olive oil. I've seen it done before and there's certainly nothing there that would aggravate the skin.

Just remember that you can't afford to re-shave an area without re-applying oil/lather: that mistake causes a ton of irritation and redness. Once you've scraped an area, you've scraped off the protection and need to re-apply oil/lather before you can scrape again.
post #4 of 16
Thread Starter 
Good points. I'll definitely remember that about scented products. Thanks!

I did learn a lot about the contours of my face while I was using the DE, and now that I'm back to the regular cartridge razor, my shaves have still improved a bit. I'm only shaving WITH the grain now too, so I don't get a very close shave but it's easier on my skin.

I want to try the DE again, but I've gotta get a brush first I think. I think I've pretty much decided to get "Edwin Jagger Medium Best Badger from the English Shaving Company." Only tihng left to figure out is which soaps/creams to use with it.
post #5 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by stvwrd View Post
Good points. I'll definitely remember that about scented products. Thanks!

I did learn a lot about the contours of my face while I was using the DE, and now that I'm back to the regular cartridge razor, my shaves have still improved a bit. I'm only shaving WITH the grain now too, so I don't get a very close shave but it's easier on my skin.

I want to try the DE again, but I've gotta get a brush first I think. I think I've pretty much decided to get "Edwin Jagger Medium Best Badger from the English Shaving Company." Only tihng left to figure out is which soaps/creams to use with it.

I have an EJ brush and love it very much. It will work with any cream or soap. FWIW, I shave with the grain and cross-grain (out-to-in). You might try Mitchell's Wool Fat as well, that one's well-liked.
post #6 of 16
Thread Starter 
Cool. I put in the order for the EJ brush this morning. They ship to Korea though, so now I feel stupid for not getting it a long time ago

I'm leaning towards the milled soaps if only for how long they last. I'll check out the wool fat one you suggested too.
post #7 of 16
http://badgerandblade.com/ is a good resource for shaving. Nivea sensetive skin aftershave is nice, doesn't smell much, and is good bargain since most of the nice shaving stuff gets pricey quickly, except for blades. For shaving brushes, badger brushes are considered better than boar or synthetic hair. I own a vulfix badger brush, but I got kind of lucky since I ordered a cheaper brush from a shaving site, and they were out and sent a nicer vulfix.
post #8 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by stvwrd View Post
First off, apologies for starting off yet another shaving thread. I've read through most of the previous ones in detail, but a lot of the recommended products like crabtree and evelyn brushes, Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood shaving cream, etc, don't appear to be carried anymore.

I'm returning to the states this week for vacation and I want to get started in DE shaving. Actually I already tried last December when I got a Christmas gift of a DE razor and a supply of Proraso products, but it always took me 45 minutes to shave and Proraso felt like it turned my skin into sandpaper (maybe drying it out? I don't really know why, but I just did not like it). I eventually gave it up. I started out strong but I had too many painful, bloody, shaves, and my ingrown hair problem on my neck just seemed to be more aggravated.

I want to give it another go, and I need to buy it all in one shot since I'm only in-country for two weeks, and money IS an object.

I need a brush, shaving cream/soap (to be honest, I don't really understand the difference), and maybe some pre-shave oil (Does it really help that much? I've just been using olive oil, and I like it fine), or after shave (usually I use a drug-store brand after shave balm with moisturizing properties. I'm open to suggestion).

I'm thinking about starting here:

http://westcoastshaving.com/index.ph...products_id=92

Then maybe get the eshave travel kit, or the mini-kit to try different fragrances of their shaving cream.

I already have a big sampler pack of blades and the DE razor itself. Taylor of Old Bond Street-Sandalwood seems highly recommended on SF, but they don't have the tub anymore. I can only find a tube on Amazon. Is it the same thing?: http://www.amazon.com/Taylor-Old-Bon...ecc_rvi_cart_2

Thoughts? Advice? Anyone had similar trials and tribulations trying to make the switch?

Lots of things here...

Your first few shaves will take a while. Don't worry, you'll be able to do it in a few minutes soon enough (BUT DO NOT RUSH SHAVING! That will only cause problems!) You could be putting too much pressure on your face. Just try guiding the blade, not pushing it down or anything like that. As with the rough feeling, anytime you switch shaving methods your face will have to readjust, I mean, your dragging a blade across your face! Of course it'll be an odd sensation at first! No need to worry about that though.

When shaving, you can work the grain in two steps: with then across. You'll get a great shave that way.

As Thomas said, avoid anything with a strong fragrance due to your skin. I'd say go with West Coast Shave's products as they are an affiliate. I have never used their services but they carry quality products and I have a hard time believing they would become an affiliate with anything less than stellar customer service. You could also go to Art of Shaving if you would like to get a better idea of what you like, although they do tend to be a little expensive, but they are almost ubiquitous in malls now.

With the soap vs. cream distinction, I've found its largely a matter of preference. There are some differences yes, but I'd say get a sample of gel and a small soap, see which one you prefer. I wouldn't concern yourself with the differences. Right now, the distinctions likely won't matter to you and if you get either a soap or gel from a quality manufacturer you will get a great shave either way.

Pre-shave after shave....If you like olive oil that's fine. Since I've started using Art of Shaving's pre-shave oil I have no desire to switch. That stuff is amazing. Never used any other pre-shave oil so not sure if there are better, all I'm saying is I am quite content. Once again, if you have a decent brand's PSO, I'm sure you'll be fine. Aftershave--avoid ANYTHING AT ALL with alcohol. A moisturizing AS is a must. I use Loreal for men's aftershave moisturizer and it is great, cheap, readily available etc. Don't think you are done however! An alum block and styptic pencil should also be purchased. Don't spend more than about 10 bucks or so on the AB and around $5 for the pencil. Put a little water on the AB, rub on your face and it will seal up the skin. A refreshing tingling sensation should be experienced. It will also tell you which areas you cut too close as the sensation will be most noticeable there. The pencil is to stop bleeding/big cuts. Just dab it on those areas.

The eShave kit is a fantastic value although I'd try to find a cheap stand for the brush. Having it suspended with the bristles down is the only way to store it properly. The other products you mentioned are generally good.

To repeat what was said earlier: BandB is a great resource, you've got to reapply cream/soap once you've shaved it off (I think that will solve most problems you mentioned). Seriously, just take your time shaving, learning, and getting used to your new method, it will pay off.
post #9 of 16
All good advice here! Badger and Blade is a fantastic resource for everything DE shaving-related. One thing that can help is start out using a blade that's relatively forgiving to the skin on your face and neck, and Merkur blades are the ones people usually start with (they're included in a lot of different starter kits, etc.). They're good for conditioning your skin until you're ready for a sharper blade. Definitely don't push on the blade, let the weight of the razor do all the work, and try not to stop and start if you can. And, of course, if it hurts, stop! Product-wise, I love Art of Shaving stuff. I use their lavender shaving cream and occasionally their pre-shave oil. I've also used Origins preshave oil (a gift from my wife) and it works well, too. Nivea extra-sensitive soothing balm (or whatever the name is) is a great value for aftershave. It works well, is $6/bottle, and lasts a long time. My big thing with DE shaving was rushing it. Once I started planning on taking my time shaving, really examining my face and seeing how best to shave each area, things started getting better. It probably took me 6 months to get truly comfortable with the shave and getting that fantastic, close, smooth shave we all want. Try to treat shaving as a pleasurable time for yourself, be patient, and you'll get there!
post #10 of 16
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the in-depth discussion everyone. I already ordered the Edwin Jagger brush. At this point I'm just deciding what soap/creams to get. I heard there's an Art of Shaving and a Crabtree and Evelyn in a mall not far from where I'm going so I may just go check it out.

I'm thinking I'll order a cream and a soap off of Amazon and look at pre/post shave treatment stuff, especially razor burn and ingrown hair treatments when I get in town. If I don't find something in the first few days I should have enough time to put another Amazon order in.

I'm not sure what the problem was when I first tried DE shaving. It would hurt all day long after a shave. I was shaving with the grain, and then a 2nd pass against the grain. I also didn't have a brush, so I'm sure that was part of it.

I'm bookmarking this thread so I can come back and re-read all the advice you all gave me over the next week or so while I figure out what I'm gonna do.

Thanks!
post #11 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by Terria View Post
All good advice here! Badger and Blade is a fantastic resource for everything DE shaving-related.

One thing that can help is start out using a blade that's relatively forgiving to the skin on your face and neck, and Merkur blades are the ones people usually start with (they're included in a lot of different starter kits, etc.). They're good for conditioning your skin until you're ready for a sharper blade.

Definitely don't push on the blade, let the weight of the razor do all the work, and try not to stop and start if you can. And, of course, if it hurts, stop!

Product-wise, I love Art of Shaving stuff. I use their lavender shaving cream and occasionally their pre-shave oil. I've also used Origins preshave oil (a gift from my wife) and it works well, too. Nivea extra-sensitive soothing balm (or whatever the name is) is a great value for aftershave. It works well, is $6/bottle, and lasts a long time.

My big thing with DE shaving was rushing it. Once I started planning on taking my time shaving, really examining my face and seeing how best to shave each area, things started getting better. It probably took me 6 months to get truly comfortable with the shave and getting that fantastic, close, smooth shave we all want.

Try to treat shaving as a pleasurable time for yourself, be patient, and you'll get there!

really thx
post #12 of 16
two points to consider.

re: aftershave, I use Thayer's Medicated but it's not a miracle worker. Take your time and make sure you don't scrape the same area twice without reapplying lather or oil. That alone should cut your irritation.

Also: start slowly, no against-the-grain passes for a while. Cross-grain should get you close enough. If you're getting ingrown hairs, then you're cutting too close and should back off on the closeness.
post #13 of 16
You mentioned earlier that you have a several different blades - if you skin is sensitive then I would give Derby's a shot (if you have them). Everybody is different but I have tried about 7 different blades so far and nothing is as forgiving as the Derby for my face. Also, keep in mind use LIGHT PRESSURE. Try holding the razor at the bottom tip of the handle with the tips of your fingers. This will force you to use minimum pressure and should help a great deal. Good luck and don't give up!
post #14 of 16
There´s already some good advice here. Just to add a couple of things:

1. Start with a relatively forgiving blade such as the Derby or Israeli "red" Personna.

2. Good technique is especially important if you have sensitive skin. Mantic has posted some good videos on Youtube.
http://www.youtube.com/user/mantic59

If you prefer to read about technique:
http://leisureguy.wordpress.com/2006...ng-experience/
post #15 of 16
If you're face hurt all day after a shave, I'd put a large wager on you pressing too hard with your razor. You pretty much have to press with a cartridge razor, but a DE requires no pressure. Even when you thin you're putting no pressure on the razor, you are. This is one of the hardest things to overcome and it just takes time using the razor. Finding the correct angle will also help. You want to be slicing the beard, not tugging or scraping it out. I even think this is a much larger problem than the Proraso. Sure, some people just have a reaction to the eucalyptus or menthol, but what you're describing sounds like just a rough shave. Of course, there are plenty of products with little to know scent and others that are designed for sensitive skin.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Health & Body
Styleforum › Forums › Lifestyle › Health & Body › Yet Another Shaving Thread