Walking VS. Elliptical

jgold47 · Jun 9, 2009

If I only have 30 minutes at lunch, which am I better off doing? I am planning on getting back into running as soon as I get some LBS down (knee is bothering me) and some new running shoes.

lefty · Jun 9, 2009

Doesn't matter.

This is worth a read before buying new shoes" http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/mosl...ste-money.html

lefty

jgold47 · Jun 9, 2009

Originally Posted by lefty

Doesn't matter.

This is worth a read before buying new shoes" http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/mosl...ste-money.html

lefty

what doesnt matter?

Are you saying they are equivlent?

I need new shoes because I pronate pretty badly and get terrible shin splints. I had/have a pair of stabilty shoes which were a godsend, but they are toast now.

grundletaint · Jun 9, 2009

i'd say, if you're having knee issues already, to stay with elliptical since it's much lower impact. i shattered my heel a few years ago and have had extensive discussions with doctors/PTs about avoiding impact excercises as much as you can if you have some sort of leg injury, especially if you're currently experiencing pain with it. sucks, cause i'd rather run....but i also want to stay away from walkers/wheelchairs as long as possible.

lefty · Jun 9, 2009

Originally Posted by jgold47

what doesnt matter?

Are you saying they are equivlent?

I need new shoes because I pronate pretty badly and get terrible shin splints. I had/have a pair of stabilty shoes which were a godsend, but they are toast now.

If you're crippled, go to PT.
If the goal of walking or the elliptical is to prep you for running, it doesn't matter. Neither will.
If the goal is fat loss, 30 minutes a couple of times a week on either will have about the same effect. Very little.

lefty

js4design · Jun 11, 2009

since you say elliptical, i assume you're working out in an office gym during lunch. if they have this equipment i'd recommend cycling and rowing. much more likely to see results than walking. (my dad actually has a theory that walking makes you fat, explaining why the most of the people you ever see walking for fitness are fat)

retroaaron · Jun 13, 2009

I'd recommend a stationary bike or, in your case, an elliptical

TheDarkKnight · Jun 13, 2009

This may not be practical because of where you live, but hiking has been fantastic for fitness for me.

I have a prolapsed disc in my back and ankle niggles/ knee ache due to a car crash when I was 18

The uneven ground and hills of hiking really help sort these niggles out. It is also great for muscle tone and fitness.

Eliptical trainers and gym equipment is such a repetitive motion, they cause my ankle and knee problems.

Plus hiking is much more fun. And Free (minus travel to the hills etc)

Rambo · Jun 13, 2009

Rowing machine FTW. No leg impact, full body workout, and it's killer cardio to boot.

Jbreen1 · Jun 13, 2009

If your trying to lose weight, it doesn't matter what you do as long as you keep a steady heart rate at about 90-120bpm.

APK · Jun 13, 2009

Elliptical is fine if you have knee issues, but it's really easy to get lazy on those things. Seems like most people on see on them use the handrails to completely brace themselves, negating a lot of the benefits.

Jbreen1 · Jun 13, 2009

Originally Posted by APK

Elliptical is fine if you have knee issues, but it's really easy to get lazy on those things. Seems like most people on see on them use the handrails to completely brace themselves, negating a lot of the benefits.

That's not really true. As long as you keep an eye on your heart rate and keep it at an acceptable level depending on your goals it's fine to brace yourself. I know many competitive bodybuilders who do this to keep lean or cut for a contest.

why · Jun 13, 2009

Originally Posted by Jbreen1

That's not really true. As long as you keep an eye on your heart rate and keep it at an acceptable level depending on your goals it's fine to brace yourself. I know many competitive bodybuilders who do this to keep lean or cut for a contest.

yfarmanara · Jun 13, 2009

Originally Posted by Jbreen1

If your trying to lose weight, it doesn't matter what you do as long as you keep a steady heart rate at about 90-120bpm.

You should probably be going a little harder than that if you're looking for the weight loss zone. 120-130 is more of a warm-up zone, which is why it's going to be pretty hard to lose weight if all you do is walking. I don't know if I've ever had my heart-rate up that high just walking. Unless if was after the bar, and I was trying to get a burrito before the place closed.

APK · Jun 13, 2009

Originally Posted by Jbreen1

That's not really true. As long as you keep an eye on your heart rate and keep it at an acceptable level depending on your goals it's fine to brace yourself. I know many competitive bodybuilders who do this to keep lean or cut for a contest.

Yeah, you're right. The body will get worked just same whether you're allowing the handles to prop you up or forcing your body to maintain the majority of your balance. One is certainly not any tougher than the other.

Walking VS. Elliptical

Distinguished Member

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

Well-Known Member

Distinguished Member

Timed Out

Distinguished Member

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member

Well-Known Member

Stylish Dinosaur

FEATURED PRODUCTS

Similar threads

Featured Sponsor

Definitely full canvas only

Half canvas is fine

Really don't care

Depends on fabric

Depends on price

Forum Sponsors

Forum statistics

FOLLOW STYLEFORUM ON: