Quote:
Originally Posted by
Holdfast 
I've read a few of your interesting posts about the custom orders you've made over the months/years and have just one question: have you ever had a bespoke or MTM order where you got exactly what you ordered, executed completely correctly? Not being snarky, just genuinely curious. You seem to have had some rotten luck over the years.
(I know from experience that bespoke anything is subject to a certain "element of surprise" on arrival, but still, your experience strike me as more variable than most).
Not a problem-it is a good question. "More variable than most" - a good way to put it. Yes-Maftei on first pair of shoes they did for me-ankle boot monk straps. Also, they resoled/fit my Klemann's-fit perfect now. The second pair of monk low quarters fit good, but have some minor problems. The third pair they made for me a great-semi brogue low qaurters. The fourth pair I ordered from them, I just cancelled b/c they were so far off in fit and style that I sent them back. 9 months later I had no response, so I just cancelled the order-they kindly obliged without disent. I suspect Koji Suzuki as well, based on the trial shoe. I will find out this month.
Also, keep in mind, although I had a problem with Cleverly, it was fixed and the shoe fits exteremely well-I will go back to Cleverly in the future. One maker who I think made the nicest shoes that I have to date are those made by JP Myhre-by far his leather is the best and I like the shape the best. I finally got the shoe to fit by having the local cobbler stretch it for a couple of days. Now-I think had JP Myhre actually seen the trial shoe on my feet for himself, I think that I would not have had a problem with the fit-but it doesn't matter, as now they are one of my best fitting shoes.
Now, Dimitri Gomez-I won't go back to him. Stretching didn't even phase them. Koji is working on them as we speak. I think Manton once said that all the makers have their own idiosyncratic problems-none of them are "perfect" or something to that effect-I agree. However, still light years ahead of RTW.