Not a trick question - I am genuinely interested. I registered only a couple of weeks ago so I missed that whole controversy. However someone added a post to it yesterday so I was able to read it. I must say I am quite excited about trying these shirts. I've got a ton of Borrelli, Lorenzini, Brioni etc. but very few of them are perfect. Neck is a bit small on some, sleeves a bit short on others, collar a bit small etc. I got them all for $10-$40 a shirt so I wasn't complaining too much. However I would gladly wear a perfect fitting machine-made shirt with a great collar than I would a Borrelli that doesn't look quite right on me. And from the description and pictures on the website they are a step up in quality from some of the Thomas Pink, Faconnable, older Purple Label (the new ones are made by Lorenzini,) and lower end Zegna shirts I have. I'm going to order two or three shirts and if I'm happy with them then I'll be ordering 3 more per month after that. If they look presentable all my other shirts are going to end up in ebay. And it could be a dream come true for my father who wears a 19" collar and a 38" sleeve. I'll let you guys know how it goes. And if any of you have more comments, good or bad, on shirts you have already ordered please let me know.