All in all after 3 years of trying RRL it is not an easy brand to buy. It is overpriced (I guess we all know that and many purchase only on promo) and quality and vfm are hit and miss. After a lot of back and forth for AW13 (I kept only 3 sweaters) and now with SS14 being so hit and miss I think it might be time to take a breather. A shame as many of the pieces are quite tasty looking when viewed online.
Pretty much exactly my thoughts and my experience. And when you factor in the labor, as you noted in another part of your post, literally zero reason for the pricing. AW sweaters were indeed a back and forth and I didn't keep a single one. Fits were either all over the place or the quality was just poor. I honestly was rather shocked as it was my first RRL experience. You're right too, pieces look great online.
That said I do love my Dixon jacket from AW. Looks great on and I'm pleased with the quality considering the sale price.