Well you would be the best judge considering you know your own wardrobe best. What pants and color combonations do you have, maybe we can help you out? Post pics if you want, couldn't hurt.
I would, but I am completey camera-less at the moment. The shirt looks decent with my APCs, but not great with my favourite chinos, and only works with less than half of my shoes. Given that I'm on a tight budget, I feel like this shirt is too much of a novelty item. If I could afford to buy a whole bunch of shirts, I'd keep it, but as it is, I think my money is better redirected to an item I can wear more. And Frances May is really easy to deal with about returns and exchanges.