You bought shirts for 60% off, got free shipping / returns, plus $20 and you're not happy. If you REALLY wanted the pullover you would just BUY the pullovers. You wouldn't wait for a flash sale and then get it.
This thread is almost as bad as the APC thread now. Sure there may be some sisters shirts in the mix and a few ones cut a bit off, but you are buying them from MyHabit what do you expect? And how many people here complaining actually have a good sample of Gitman shirts to compare to? Sounds like a bunch of people just got sizing wrong or something like that.