Lousy. Yeah, better than the first two (maybe just because all the action kept some of the god awful dialogue at bay), but still lousy. Why'd you guys above like it so much? Qualms: --Palpatine taking a whole 2 minutes of dialogue to turn Anakin, which involved convincing him to kill all his budies. --The extent of the wookie panet's role seemed to be Lucas thinking "Hey, people like wookies." --When did R2D2 become such a badass? --Kenobi calling his droid R4, when it was obviously an R2 unit. --No Boba Fett. --And yeah, Lucas, we get the point: you like dismemberments. --The whole movie was a friggin' cartoon. I did like the final dialogue between Kenobi and Anakin, probably because Hayden Christensen didn't say anything and the job was left to the decent actor. The whole scene was done pretty well, I guess.