I just bought the Napoli Navy Hopsack. Between the Caine and Napoli, I prefer and would recommend the Napoli. IMO, the Napoli's open patch pockets and the welt breast pocket allow it to be more casual than the Caine. The advantage being that, for me, it would look great with jeans, as well as lightweight casual summer clothes (madras, linen, white cotton, etc.) … but still quite dressy when paired with wool trousers, shirt and tie; or the matching trousers. The Caine has the advantage of looking dressier than the Napoli with the matching trousers. Just my 2¢.