Originally Posted by Skydiver Nick
Cool idea but I think the recipient should be able to choose if he wants that done. I would like to know what I am smoking because I hope that someone will put me on to a cigar that I have never tried before!
The point is that you smoke it blind. Decide you love it/hate it, and post a review. Lo and Behold, the sender reveals what cigar it was, and you're either surprised you liked such a cheapo smoke, or surprised you disliked a premium cigar, etc. But either way, you still find out what the cigar was.