How about appointing a new WAYWRN editor each week? The previous week's editor appoints the next week's. We get to see what different people choose. Everyone still gets to comment, agree, disagree, post pictures of cats talking, etc.
That's a great idea.
I appoint you for next week. When you're done, you appoint the next person, and so on.
I still think focusing on the daily column would be the best thing.