I got my charcoal 2B a few weeks ago from Ned's. There was a little mixup on the final delivery (sleeve buttons weren't functional, though it was on the work order), which set me back a few weeks, but the final product was quite good in terms of fit. I must have caught them at a busy time because the service -which had been very very good through the measurements and first two fittings - was a bit off for pickup (it was really busy there towards the end).
Anyway, I also had a Greenfield-measured BB suit done and just tried that one on today (MTM, no basted fitting, just some final tweaks such as sleeve and trouser length).
My verdict? the overall construction of the BB suit looks a bit more solid to me on a quick glance, but Ned's fit wins hands down. Their jacket made me look GOOD! The Brooks jacket is nice and roomy but I didn't see that much difference from OTR in all honesty.....they are nipping the waist for me so we'll see if that helps.
The Ned pants were also quite slimmiing , though I may get the waist nipped a bit (my fault as I am trying to lose the spare tire). The BB pants are more comfy in the seat (no surprise) but also a bit looser all the way down. The NED suit is definitley a trimmer slimmer look.
I am actually getting a second pr of pants made from Ned, not only for the charcoal suit they made me, but in the matching fabric for the BB suit! So I am happy with them for the money as of now. We'll see how their suit holds up over interviews and a year of work before I go back for more.
I really wanted to get a Logsdail suit but the price is beyond me at present. I basically got the two suits and 2 extra pants for less than one Logsdail MTM suit. Though I reckon that one would have looked and fit quite nicely indeed......
BUt if the BB is true MTM then I'd say Ned's is 'custom' enough for me. The fit is the best I've had yet and quite good for the money imho.....