Originally Posted by Limniscate
Should I be buying wider collars for my face if I plan to button the top bottom? This shirt is going to be relegated to casual wear only.
Unless you're trying to make an ironic statement, I would never wear this collar shape with a tie or buttoned all the way. I'd certainly go for shorter points, and also probably wider spread.
Have a quick look through some WAYWN posts to see what collars you like and what you don't like. I personally have a strong preference for a collar that's widespread enough that the points are not or barely visible when my jacket is on. Others prefer a medium spread - but even with a narrower spread, the point length here just doesn't work