Hi guys. I know this isn't the traditional style that you guys prefer for dress shoes for suits but I like to be a little different. So I need you opinion of which shoe you guys like better to go along with a dark navy suit.
If you want something "different" then may I suggest you take a look at more fashion forward brands like Santoni, Sutor Mantellasi and the other Italian brands. The 2 you posted seems too busy to be worn with a suit (or with anything 'SF approved' for that matter)