What's the consensus on a black McAllister? Is the broguing too much on a black shoe? Would probably prefer a black strand or 5th Ave, but they never go on sale on Amazon in my size. I will probably only buy one pair of black shoes for a while (hence why I lean toward the 5th Ave, given that it is probably the most versatile in terms of formality). Before anyone recommends it, I find the PA too plain/stubby for my tastes.
7/20/14 at 8:05pm