Just got my black melange stark for TBS. At 5'8-9" and 60 kg (130 lbs) ( or a better reference: a small in just about anything W+H, XS in anything Club Monaco ), the S stark fits me great.
The entire the thing is snug especially around the wrist and forearm. The length is great and just covers my jean pockets.
The black melange is probably best described as a really dark charcoal. It's been hard to tell based on all the variation in photos.
I also had a chance to try on...