I have a question for you masters out there. The only pair of nice shoes I have(read: not rockport, banana republic) are a pair of AE bel airs. They are 11s, but I could probably fit 10.5s in them.
I'd like to buy some other, nicer, shoes on ebay, but not having been to their stores and not being able to try them on locally leaves me with a challenge.
Right now the some ferragamo loafers are #1 on the hit list. Biggest difficulty for me is also foot width.