Originally Posted by JG000
Best fit appears to be the Jcrew 38R (in the "action shot"). Looks VERY good for an OTR piece, though I would shorten the sleeves ever so slightly.
With that said, the general rule of thumb is find a size you feel comfortable in and then go a size down. Case in point 40 -> 38
I've never heard that before.
So... you shouldn't be comfortable in what you're wearing?