I said it skirts too tight, not that it was and I agree that is doesn't pull and otherwise seems ok in that sense. Teger ripped the color combination and I tend to agree with him. This combo should work, but kinda says "spring" up top and "fall" below.
I did a sorta similar outfit in MC Casual and got ripped by Teger for it. I think the pants should be a lighter shade of brown to work completely well here. Personally, I don't think the jacket is too short, but it is skating the line of too tight.
NOBD- I thought I liked the buttons to start with, now I'm lukewarm. They look better in the closeup rather than the overall shot, coat looks more navy in the close up shot. Maybe that's what's doing it.