or Connect
New Posts  All Forums:

Posts by scurvyfreedman

Samwell is obviously exaggerating about his father's abuse. He's the Cowardly Lion. I'm sure his father was terribly disappointed with him, but GRRM has established the unreliable narrator - they're all unreliable. I like Samwell, but I don't believe him completely. His fear and passivity have caused problems. The delays in travels lead to a death or two. Acts of omission can be as bad as acts of commission.Brandon is too young to judge. His biggest tests are ahead...
I'm not giving it to the Starks. Ned kept a bastard in his wife's house for years - came home from war with one who was just as old as his trueborn son with Catelyn. Even if it was a lie, that's a terrible burden to place on his wife - she believed her entire marriage that he broke his vow with her despite his reputation as the "honorable Ned Stark."Robb broke his marriage pact. While it was because he took Jeyne Westerling's maidenhead and didn't want to dishonor her,...
Some people refer to them as San-San. Sandor and Sansa have a very complicated relationship. His drunk speeches to her are one of the highlights of A Clash of Kings. It's in one of those speeches, after she thanks him (thank you Ser) for either saving her from the Kingsguard beating at the orders of Joffrey or the rape by the mob, he tells her how he was burned and why he hates Knights - "bugger on your Ser"; that she should give up her fanciful belief that Knights...
Ser Barristan WoW chapters:I had mentioned he had two chapters, but realized they weren't in the link I posted the other day. Here are the summaries- Don't read if you haven't finished ADwD, they won't make the least bit of sense and they will spoil plot as well. [[SPOILER]]
Good stuff. But, as you said, Arryn raised his banners and sent Robert and Ned to raise armies. Without his leadership it wouldn't have happened. Lord Hoster was obviously suggesting restraint initially, because he didn't want Brandon and his party going to KL to demand Rhaegar.All that said, I don't think it was a foregone conclusion that Robert would be king when Aerys was ultimately deposed. I think he would have been fine had it been Jon Arryn, even without an...
Gregor Clegane also qualifies.
I respect Stannis more than any of the other claimants. Renly was a douche to try to step around his older brother. Joffrey isn't exactly the monster portrayed on the show, but he's not far behind given what he did to Sansa and others. Didn't he torture animals too? Balon is just annoying. I can't stand the Iron Born chapters on Pyke. And, Robb is an idiot. Sure, be King in the North. But, once you leave the King's Peace stay in the North. Why do all that damage. ...
Yes, the first he is Stannis.But, the second piece is that the Robert probably couldn't have held the throne against the Lannisters. Tywin always had the largest host and the ability to "seize the throne." But, Robert was King even though Twyin could have seized the throne. Tywin could have preserved the throne for Aerys too. But, Aerys had mocked him when he suggested Cersei marry Rhaegar. So, Tywin stayed out of the conflict when Robert first rose against the crown....
And a complete simpleton.
The ability to seize the throne is nothing. Robert was King. That's why he has the claim of right. He's the rightful heir to his dead brother who was King. That's how primogeniture and inheritance rights works in the Seven Kingdoms, except Dorne, which provides for inheritance to oldest regardless of sex, so women can inherit.Robert was the rightful King because he deposed the sitting dynasty and all of the Lords Paramount swore fealty to him. Starks, Arryns, and...
New Posts  All Forums: