I think number 2 is the best combo. Hard to tell without a jacket, but it looks just passable. From the angle, the tie looks too long.
The 1st tie is way too casual. I would never wear it, even for casual wear.
In number 3, there are too many lines going in too many different directions. The gingham has lines going horizontally and vertically. Then you have the tie which has many different colors going diagonally in both directions.
In number 4, the pindots are the...