You might get more replies over on SW&D. I just got a pair a few weeks ago and am very happy with them. The leather isn't amazing quality, but it is very soft and the boots were comfortable immediately. I like how they look and they've become my go-to winter casual boots. They've broken in nicely and I like them even better now that they are showing some wear. (BTW wait for one of their frequent sales.)
I'm interested in the MTM shirts. Should I just go ahead and order the shirt that is close to my measurements and contact you if I need to make adjustments? Or do I need to make arrangements in advance?
Probably an extra small, but it is likely that the sleeves will be too long for you. I fall between the XS and S in J Crew and have just decided to look elsewhere for sweaters that fit better (not that I have found them at a similar price point, yet).