9.5FUK (Moore), should have taken a 10 or wider size. I am getting pinky toe crush or otherwise they fit great (reason I am selling). I wear 10EUK in G&G.Yes, but the Moore would be perfectly fine if I didn't know about the St. James.
I have the Moore a 1/2 size smaller than the St. James, so it would be an unfair comparison in terms of fit.G&G has slightly better leather, tighter waist. I think the sole treatment are a tie. All based on my uneducated observations.