If you insist on having people eyeball recommendations from photographs, why dont you just send the photos to ModernTailor and ask them their opinion? I would imagine you are a valued customer by this point. Then again, I suppose its better for them if you just keep asking people to guess numbers.
Could I suggest that you all consider adopting a rule on SF that the seller assumes risk of loss and it must be included in the terms of all sales? I understand that you want to keep sales in the community informal, but that way there would be no ambiguity. Not everyone is as standup as kunk.